Governments wrestle the spam dilemma

By Wendy Brewer, PC Advisor |  Business Add a new comment

Government officials and industry associations today met at the House of Commons to discuss possible solutions to the ever-expanding problem of unsolicited e-mail.

The EU directive to fight spam, which becomes law in the UK in October, enforces an opt-in scheme so that commercial email can only be sent where the recipient has expressly agreed to receive that mail.

But the problem lies in enforcement. Firstly, EU law is only binding on European countries, so most of the areas from where spam originates - South East Asia and South America - are beyond the reach of the directive. Secondly, even within the EU there are no real rules on controlling and monitoring the opt-in clause, as implementation and enforcement are down to each member state.

"The recipient will have to have given permission, but we will not be checking where the sender acquired the recipients address from in the first place or how permission was granted," admitted Philip Gerrard, spokesman for the EU's Information Society.

Exact figures on how much of the world's internet traffic is junk mail are varied - generally pinpointed at between 30 to 70 percent - but all bodies recognise that this problem is getting worse. Antivirus firm Brightmail Inc. says spam now accounts for 48 percent of all messages across its networks, with adult content making up 19 percent of spam.

"When we developed email facilities we didn't predict that spam would be such a problem and therefore didn't build in solutions to prevent users sending anonymous emails," said Enrique Salem, spokesman at Brightmail. "What we need to do now is create transparency. If we know where these mails are coming from then we can block them."

Our current PC Advisor poll revealed that nearly a quarter (23.4 percent) of all emails received by readers are spam, while a third said that nearly all of their emails are junk, proving the ever-growing problem of unsolicited bulk email.

Spam filtering group Spamhaus estimates that 90 percent of the world's spam mail is generated by 200 identified servers, most of which are based in China and South America. It believes that by making their activities illegal, spammers will be forced further underground making it harder for them to operate.

"We don't want to legitimise spam and create rules like the US is doing, we want to make it illegal," said Spamhaus' Steven Linford.

But it is clear that legislation alone is not enough. Government officials and industry associations today met at the House of Commons to discuss possible solutions to the ever-expanding problem of unsolicited email.

The EU directive to fight spam, which becomes law in the UK in October, enforces an opt-in scheme so that commercial email can only be sent where the recipient has expressly agreed to receive that mail.

But the problem lies in enforcement. Firstly, EU law is only binding on European countries, so most of the areas from where spam originates - South East Asia and South America - are beyond the reach of the directive. Secondly, even within the EU there are no real rules on controlling and monitoring the opt-in clause, as implementation and enforcement are down to each member state.

"The recipient will have to have given permission, but we will not be checking where the sender acquired the recipients address from in the first place or how permission was granted," admitted Philip Gerrard, spokesman for the EU's Information Society.

Exact figures on how much of the world's internet traffic is junk mail are varied - generally pinpointed at between 30 to 70 percent - but all bodies recognise that this problem is getting worse. Antivirus firm Brightmail says spam now accounts for 48 percent of all messages across its networks, with adult content making up 19 percent of spam.

"When we developed email facilities we didn't predict that spam would be such a problem and therefore didn't build in solutions to prevent users sending anonymous emails," said Enrique Salem, spokesman at Brightmail. "What we need to do now is create transparency. If we know where these mails are coming from then we can block them."

Our current PC Advisor poll revealed that nearly a quarter (23.4 percent) of all emails received by readers are spam, while a third said that nearly all of their emails are junk, proving the ever-growing problem of unsolicited bulk email.

Spam filtering group Spamhaus estimates that 90 percent of the world's spam mail is generated by 200 identified servers, most of which are based in China and South America. It believes that by making their activities illegal, spammers will be forced further underground making it harder for them to operate.

"We don't want to legitimise spam and create rules like the US is doing, we want to make it illegal," said Spamhaus' Steven Linford.

    Add a comment

    Post a comment using one of these accounts
    Or join now
    At least 6 characters

    Note: Comment will appear soon after you have activated your account.
    Obscene/spam comments will be removed and accounts suspended.
    The information you submit is subject to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.

    ITworld LIVE

    BusinessWhite Papers & Webcasts

    White Paper

    Insiders Can Ruin Your Company. Take Action.

    Did you know that 80 percent of threats to an organization come from the inside? The threat from insiders is often overlooked in organizations worldwide. This white paper from NetIQ, discusses key technology solutions that help to prevent and detect insider threats.

    White Paper

    Ten Steps to an Enterprise Mobility Strategy

    Enterprise employees are more mobile, relishing the ability to work productively anywhere, at any time. They may use any means to get connected, often creating financial and security risks for your company. Discover how to get control of your enterprise mobility strategy and ensure mobile worker productivity with these ten steps.

    White Paper

    What You Need to Know About the Costs of Mobility

    Mobile workers want to get connected anywhere, at any time, often at any cost. Enterprise mobility is often a hidden "black" budget in your company. Ensure that your traveling employees are productive everywhere, even while you control cost and security, through an enterprise mobility strategy.

    White Paper

    The 2011 iPass Mobile Enterprise Report

    This industry survey covers trends, recommendations and a policy guide on managing Enterprise Mobility for IT management and CIOs. Get data on employee device liability, as well as smartphone/tablet penetration, budget control and provisioning. Find out how your organization compares, how to ensure mobile worker productivity, and control costs.

    White Paper

    Smarter Commerce is redefining value chain visibility

    Smarter Commerce is redefining the value chain in the age of the customer. It starts with putting the customer at the center of your operations - which of itself is not a new idea - however, truly operationalizing this strategy is not easy.

    See more White Papers | Webcasts

    Ask a question

    Ask a Question