Waste Management sues SAP over ERP implementation
The trash-disposal giant Waste
Management is suing SAP,
saying top SAP executives participated in a fraudulent sales scheme that resulted
in a failed ERP (enterprise resource planning) implementation.
Waste Management said it is seeking recovery of more than US$100 million in
project expenses, as well as "the savings and benefits that the SAP software
was promised to deliver to Waste Management."
An SAP spokesman said via e-mail Thursday that "as a matter of policy
SAP does not comment on ongoing litigation."
In 2005, Waste Management was looking for a new revenue management system,
according to a company statement. "SAP proposed its Waste and Recycling
product and claimed it was a tested, working solution that had been developed
with the needs of Waste Management in mind," the Waste Management statement
reads in part.
SAP promised that the software could be fully implemented throughout all of
Waste Management within 18 months, according to the statement.
"From the beginning, SAP assured Waste Management that its software was
an 'out-of-the-box' solution that would meet Waste Management's needs without
any customization or enhancements," the statement reads. "Unfortunately,
Waste Management ultimately learned that these representations were not true."
Waste Management said product demonstrations by SAP prior to the deal employed
"'fake software environments, even though these demonstrations were represented
to be the actual software."
Waste Management's original complaint, filed in Harris County, Texas district
court, said senior SAP executives, including SAP Americas' president and CEO,
Bill McDermott, participated in the "rigged and manipulated" demos.
The company filed suit against SAP Americas and SAP AG on March 20 after "months
of discussions with SAP and a recent consensual, three-day mediation that SAP
ended after day two," according to the statement.
The action followed a lengthy initial courtship and falling out between the
companies, detailed at length in Waste Management's court filing.
SAP officials held meetings with the company throughout the summer and fall
of 2005, according to the complaint. Shai Agassi, a former executive board member,
was among the SAP executives present at one meeting on June 17, 2005, in Walldorf,
Germany, according to the complaint.
"At that meeting, SAP AG executives and engineers represented that the
software was a mature solution and conducted a demonstration consisting of what
they represented was the actual SAP Waste and Recycling software," the
complaint states. The company later discovered that the software was a "mock-up
version of that software intended to deceive Waste Management," according
to the complaint. SAP has admitted to this in "internal documents,"
the complaint states.
SAP also demonstrated the "fake software" at subsequent sales presentations,
according to the complaint.
Waste Management ultimately signed a sales pact with SAP on Oct. 3, 2005, according
to the court filing.
"Almost immediately following execution of the agreements, the SAP implementation
team discovered significant 'gaps' between the software's functionality and
Waste Management's business requirements," it states.
"Waste Management has discovered that these gaps were already known to
the product development team in Germany even before the SLA was signed. Instead
of admitting what it knew at the time -- that the software lacked basic functionality
to run Waste Management's business -- SAP undertook an elaborate fraud to perpetuate
the original fraud and to recover additional money from Waste Management."
Members of SAP's implementation team blamed Waste Management for the functional
gaps and submitted change orders requiring that Waste Management pay for fixing
them, according to the complaint.
In addition, the complaint alleges, SAP originally promised that a pilot phase
in New Mexico would be up and running by Dec. 15, 2006, "but it is not
even close to being completed today."
Eventually, SAP conducted a "Solutions Review" and by summer 2007
determined the software was not an "enterprise solution" for Waste
Management's needs, according to the complaint.
SAP said that if Waste Management wished to have the software implemented on
a companywide basis, it would have to "start over" and agree to let
SAP build a new version of the product with an updated version of its enterprise
application platform, according to the complaint.
"SAP's 2007 proposal is precisely the kind of risky, expensive and time-consuming
project that Waste Management rejected from other companies two years earlier,"
the complaint states. "Indeed, the development project that SAP proposed
would drastically lengthen the implementation timetable from the original December
2007 end-date to an end-date sometime in 2010 without any assurance of success."
A Waste Management spokeswoman said the company would have no comment beyond
the statement and complaint.
IDG News Service
Symantec Backup Exec 12 and Backup Exec System Recovery 8 deliver industry leading Windows data protection and system recovery. Download this whitepaper to find out the top reasons to upgrade and how to get continuous data protection and complete system recovery.
Data and system loss — from a hard drive failure, malicious attack, natural disaster, or simple human error — can happen anytime. Don’t leave your business vulnerable. Make sure you have a secure recovery strategy in place. Symantec's latest backup and system recovery technology can efficiently restore critical applications, individual emails and documents and even restore your entire system in minutes in the event of a loss.
Businesses face a growing challenge to ensure that the IT environment is properly protected. Backup Exec 12 integrates with other applications in the Symantec family of products, to complement your current data protection strategy, keep your data securely backed up and make it recoverable when you need it most.
