December 07, 2000, 12:30 PM —
Tribal Voice Inc. has
announced it will cease offering its PowWow instant messaging service on Jan. 19, due
in part to its inability to crack into the America Online Inc. Instant Messenger (AIM)
Acquired in October by CMGion Inc. in Andover, Mass., Tribal Voice has been a critic
of AOL, together with Microsoft Corp.'s MSN and iCast Corp. in Woburn, Mass.
Based in Denver, Tribal Voice was one of 43 companies that asked the Federal
Communications Commission to investigate AOL's instant messaging policies. They say AIM
is anticompetitive because it won't allow its large member base to chat with users of
other instant messaging (IM) services, such as PowWow, although those services may be
configured to work with AIM.
In an announcement on its site, Tribal Voice told PowWow users, "Please be advised
that PowWow will no longer be supported as of January 19, 2001. The PowWow instant
messaging product, services and communities will not be available following that date.
Please take the time to find a new service before January 19, 2001, to ensure no
disruption in your instant messaging, chat and community services."
In an FAQ
page on the site explaining the reason for the shutdown, CMGion cited AOL but also
said PowWow wasn't a key part of the company's mission. "After careful review of
CMGion's business objectives and strategic direction by its new management team, CMGion
feels that the PowWow technology is not an integral part of CMGion's mission. In
addition, given the barriers associated with AOL's market dominance, the company cannot
continue to support it from a business perspective."
Dana Gardner, an analyst at the Aberdeen Group Inc. in Boston, said it's unfair to
blame AOL entirely for the failure of PowWow. "Services that don't go up to a critical
mass of users will not maintain viability," he said.
CMGI Inc, which owns a majority stake in CMGion, has also had a huge drop in its
stock price, Gardner said. "They need to find ways of curbing money loss from losing
ventures if possible. At the same time we've been expecting a shakeout of the instant
messaging situation. Whether you could point at AOL [for PowWow's failure]