October 31, 2001, 9:52 AM — Rambus Inc. and Micron Technology Inc. faced off in U.S. District Court in Delaware Tuesday over Rambus' allegations that memory manufactured by Boise, Idaho-based Micron infringed on memory design patents held by Rambus.
Both sides made presentations in front of Judge Roderick R. McKelvie Tuesday, but there were no significant decisions made, Micron spokesman Sean Mahoney said. The judge will call on both parties Monday to discuss discovery, or examination of evidence, and possibly set a date for trial, Mahoney said. Although Micron has asked for a jury trial, it is unclear at this point whether that will be granted, he added.
Rambus has seen its share of ups and downs since Toshiba Corp. became the first company to sign a license agreement for use of Rambus technology, after it was faced with a legal challenge last year.
Since then, six other chip manufacturers, including Hitachi Ltd., NEC Corp. and Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd., have agreed to pay royalties to the company. Three other companies, Micron, Infineon Technologies AG and South Korea-based Hynix Semiconductor Inc. have refused to acknowledge the company's patents and are fighting in court to avoid paying royalties.
The first to get a court date in the U.S. was Infineon, which faced off with Rambus in April in U.S. District Court in Richmond, Virginia. That case eventually saw U.S. District Judge Robert E. Payne dismiss all 57 counts of copyright infringement brought by Rambus relating to its design patents in manufacturing SDRAM (synchronous dynamic random access memory) and DDR SDRAM (double data-rate SDRAM) chips.
Rambus was dealt another blow in that case, a US$3.5 million fine in the form of punitive damages for fraud, which Judge Payne later reduced to $350,000. At that time, Judge Payne ruled that Rambus improperly obtained patents on chips that were being developed by the JEDEC (Joint Electron Device Engineering Council) while the company was participating in the group. In its defense, Rambus claimed that the JEDEC's guidelines on participation are confusing and that other members flout the rules.
The court later set aside a jury verdict from the trial clearing the memory chip designer of allegations that it set standards relating to a technology used to accelerate memory chips.
However, there are still a dozen patents involved in other Rambus cases in the U.S. and Europe, Rambus said in a statement at the time. Rambus plans to appeal the Virginia ruling and also has filed a similar lawsuit against Infineon in Germany.
Rambus also holds newly issued patents covering SDRAM and DDR SDRAM that have not yet been entered into any litigation and are not affected by the court's decision, the company said in May after Judge Payne threw out Infineon's claims.
Rambus, in Los Altos, California, can be reached at +1-650-947-5000 or on the Web at http://www.rambus.com/. Micron Technology, in Boise, Idaho, can be reached at +1-208-368-4000 or at http://www.micron.com/.
