Appeals court rules online porn law unconstitutional
A U.S. federal appeals court has ruled that a law seeking to protect children from online pornography was not constitutionally sound because it limits Web publishers' free speech.
The ruling, made by a three-judge panel of the 3rd U.S. Court of Appeals in Philadelphia Thursday, upholds an injunction against the Child Online Protection Act (COPA), which has not been enforced since it was signed into law by President Bill Clinton in late 1998.
COPA makes it illegal for Web publishers to post sexually explicit material without limiting the site to adults, by asking for a credit card number, for example.
"Once again the court has ruled in our favor and struck down a law that goes far beyond restricting pornography," said Ann Beeson, an attorney for the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), which initiated the legal challenge.
The 3rd Circuit Court issued the first injunction, saying that it is unconstitutional to judge the legality of Internet content by "contemporary community standards." However, when the case was appealed by the government to the U.S. Supreme Court, the justices ruled that the COPA was not unconstitutional on evaluation standards alone and kicked it back down to the appeals court for further review.
Beeson applauded the appellate court's upholding of the injunction Friday, saying that COPA is "another attempt by Congress to criminalize speech that is valuable for adults on the Internet."
The ACLU is representing Web publishers such as online magazine Salon.com, safe sex site Condomania.com and gay community site PlanetOut.com, Beeson added.
The government now has a choice to again appeal the case, and Beeson said she believes it will probably do so.
No one from the U.S. Department of Justice, which is defending the law, was immediately available to comment on the ruling Friday.
IDG News Service
Symantec Backup Exec 12 and Backup Exec System Recovery 8 deliver industry leading Windows data protection and system recovery. Download this whitepaper to find out the top reasons to upgrade and how to get continuous data protection and complete system recovery.
Data and system loss — from a hard drive failure, malicious attack, natural disaster, or simple human error — can happen anytime. Don’t leave your business vulnerable. Make sure you have a secure recovery strategy in place. Symantec's latest backup and system recovery technology can efficiently restore critical applications, individual emails and documents and even restore your entire system in minutes in the event of a loss.
Businesses face a growing challenge to ensure that the IT environment is properly protected. Backup Exec 12 integrates with other applications in the Symantec family of products, to complement your current data protection strategy, keep your data securely backed up and make it recoverable when you need it most.
