Did Netflix make a mistake by agreeing to pay Comcast to carry its content?


It seems to me that it would have made sense for Netflix to wait a while for the FCC to rewrite net neutrality rules now that the existing rules have been invalidated. Instead, Netflix apparently agreed to pay Comcast to deliver their content. I thought that’s what I paid my ISP for already. Doesn’t this set a poor precedent and pretty much guarantee that Netflix is going to either have to pay every ISP or have its content “slow walked” to customers. Plus, it isn’t as if Netflix is just going to pay it and be nice, they are probably going to have to charge more, which means I pay three times to see content - once for my Netflix membership, once for ISPs charges to Netflix, and once when I pay my monthly service charge.

Topic: Business
Answer this Question


3 total
Vote Up (3)

I don't think they had the time to wait for the FCC. It seems that a significant amount of Netflix customers were having problems with the service. If they had waited they might have lost those customers, and I'm sure they weren't willing to risk that. They can always revisit their agreement with Comcast later on if the FCC changes the rules.

Vote Up (3)

The planned merger of Time-Warner and Comcast will result in a single company in charge of almost ¾ of the cable industry, which means that same company will also be one of the largest ISP in the country, if not the largest. There is essentially no governmental resistance to the formation of this monopoly, and at the same time, there are essentially no net neutrality rules remaining in effect that would prevent Comcast from throttling Netflix. Comcast is a direct competitor to Netflix with RedBox, and if Comcast “encourages” Netflix streaming quality to degrade, the loss of customers is a very real possibility for Netflix.


To be fair to the ISPs, Netflix is responsible for a huge amount of traffic. Peering agreements for Netflix used CDNs like Limelight and Level 3 to push content to users. What Netflix wanted to do, and what Comcast had refused, was to use caching hardware within ISPs network to more efficiently deliver that content. This isn’t unusual, Google, Amazon and Ebay all do it. Comcast refused to do the same for Netflix until they paid up, and Netflix decided that it was worth it.

Christopher Nerney
Vote Up (2)

I understand why Netflix agreed to pay Comcast, and I'm conflicted about it. Joshua Brustein at Businessweek.com raises a good question:


"The most vulnerable companies here aren’t the likes of Netflix, which is big enough to force Comcast to the table. If nothing else, Comcast couldn’t afford to anger regulators with a fight against such a household name right now. But smaller companies will have much less leverage and could get worse terms."



Ask a question

Join Now or Sign In to ask a question.
Streaming your games for others to watch on Twitch is a big fad these days, but it looks like the company is taking the first tentative steps towards branching into other areas.
According to a new dataset, the big names in technology lag well behind actors, politicians and athletes in terms of global cultural significance
Numbers show that paid peering arrangements result in measurable increases in service quality.
The space agency has published a catalog of its software being made available to the public, and it includes code for things other than flying a rocket to the moon
Facebook can't be faulted for following the same path as other mass media channels that came before it with regards to advertising, but there are many marketers who are still hoping for something different this time around.
In today's accessible technology roundup: The impact of ARIA on screen reader developers, Quail could be threatened by software patents and how to choose an accessible color palette
A few lucky customers of the AmazonFresh grocery store will be able to order products just by speaking into the Amazon Dash, a futuristic wand that the company started offering by invitation on Friday.
Add the Amazon Fire TV to your pile of streaming media boxes
Prosecutors will recommend three-month prison sentence for insider who allegedly shared info with French blogger.
Based on the expected annual return, computer science degrees from state universities pay off better than those from private schools

White Papers & Webcasts

See more White Papers | Webcasts