How do you deal with a request for a reference about a mediocre former employee?


I received a request from a local company for a reference. The thing is the former employee who I'll call David was not a terrible employee, he wasn't very good either. He did the job with minimal competence, and called in sick a fair amount, especially on Fridays and Mondays. But David never had any really major screw ups, and didn't exceed the number of sick days allowed. More or less, he was like a character in the movie Office Space; he did the bare minimum required to keep his job. So how do I handle his reference? If I were to be absolutely honest, I would say that I wouldn't hire him again, but on the upside he probably didn't steal many office supplies. I won't actually do that, but I don't want to misrepresent him as a stellar employee either. What's the best way to deal with the situation?

Topic: Career
Answer this Question


2 total
Vote Up (16)

I think the safest way to deal with it is to simply confirm that he worked there, his position, and the period of his employment. You can include in your letter that company policy prohibits you from commenting on other aspects of the personnel files of current or former employees. This is probably the safest route for you, and avoids legal liability traps from providing either positive or negative references. It is a shame that you can't just write what you did for your question, but that's the nature of the litigious world we live in these days.

Vote Up (15)

Remember that old saying "if you can't say anything nice..." In this situation you are probably best just noting that he or she worked there, and leaving it at that. As the other answer noted, you can simply say that it's company policy not to say more than that. This way you protect yourself and avoid any possible headaches from disclosing further information.

Ask a question

Join Now or Sign In to ask a question.
The ironclad rule of resume writing is to highlight your career in reverse chronological order -- all the time, every time, right? Wrong.
The latest rankings of programming languages show a landscape that’s increasingly fragmented, but still dominated by the old guard
Select the mix of skills right for your data analytics business goals.
The agile framework for software development brings speed, flexibility and efficiency to IT-focused organizations.
IBM has initiated a new training program that will cut the pay of participating employees by 10%.
In the competition for developer talent, offering a good cup of joe could give your company an edge
Demand for security pros has never been higher, so why are salaries flat?
The secret to the security profession is to develop all the computer experience you can before you even begin to think about a career in cybersecurity.
It's time to change the way you think about attracting and hiring skilled workers. Here are six new IT roles for 2015 and advice on how to find talent to fill them.
A one-day class promises to teach digital literacy and break down the 'language barrier' between IT and business executives.