How does Eucalyptus compare with OpenStack for use in private clouds?

RomanZ

The choices for private cloud operating systems seems to boil down to a choice between OpenStack and Eucalyptus. How much difference is there between the two, and is there a consensus as to which is the superior choice for private cloud orchestration?

Answer this Question

Answers

2 total
ncharles
Vote Up (14)

 

A main difference between the two is OpenStack is an open source Rackspace spin off adopted by major vendors such as H-P, Citrix Systms and Dell.  Eucalyptus just does not have the same level of top-tier support.  Heck even NASA has used Rackspace.  But OpenStack is really still in a development mode, and I don't see it as quite at the point where it is inevitably going to become the standard open source cloud platform.  That is not to say it will not, just that the tea leaves still have not revealed the future.  

 

Eucalyptus has one thing going for it that OpenSpace does not, and it is a big thing; Eucalyptus is designed to be an API that is Amazon EC2 compatible.  Since Amazon is a HUGE player in the cloud that alone can be enough to make the decision between the two products for some companies.  Incidentally, NASA used Eucalyptus as well, until problems with scalability became and issue for NASA.  Eucalyptus also differs from OpenSource in that it is not truly open source, for good or ill.  Eucalyptus has features that OpenSource does not yet offer, such as VMware compatibility and SAN integration.       

 

jimlynch
Vote Up (14)

Hi RomanZ,

Here's a feature comparison that you might find interesting:

OpenStack Nova V.S. Eucalyptus Feature Comparison
http://hugokuo-hugo.blogspot.com/2011/05/openstack-nova-vs-eucalyptus-fe...

Ask a question

Join Now or Sign In to ask a question.
Five weeks after announcing a lower-cost subscription to Office, Microsoft today started selling Office 365 Personal to consumers.
Big data analytics are driving rapid growth for public cloud computing vendors with revenues for the top 50 public cloud providers shooting up 47% in the fourth quarter last year to $6.2 billion, according to Technology Business Review Inc.
Google has expanded its Cloud Platform to include locally hosted computing capacity, storage and data bases for the Asia-Pacific region.
The space agency has published a catalog of its software being made available to the public, and it includes code for things other than flying a rocket to the moon
Box has patched the Heartbleed security hole on its servers and has advised its customers to change their passwords.
For companies in the cloud storage business, standing out from the pack isn't getting any easier, as many competing services are racing to the bottom with both free and paid offerings.
The latest entrant into cloud-based Wi-Fi plans to apply the technique to public Wi-Fi hotspots, helping enterprises and service providers to better manage and monetize their networks.
The cloud is more than just dirt-cheap data storage and lightning-fast apps. These six innovations show that it's possible to manage servers, develop applications, run virtual machines and even sequence the human genome using cloud technology.
In today's accessible technology roundup: UK researchers find Google Glass helps Parkinson’s sufferers, a new wheelchair that can be controlled with facial expressions and a guide for using text alternatives to images on websites
Independent Oracle and SAP support provider Rimini Street will now offer integration services for customers who want to adopt SaaS (software-as-a-service) offerings from the likes of Salesforce.com and Workday.
Join us:
Facebook

Twitter

Pinterest

Tumblr

LinkedIn

Google+

randomness