Will the Court decision in the Aereo case impact other cloud computing companies?


The Supreme Court just ruled against Aereo, the company that gave out antennas to subscribers that allowed them to send the signal to a cloud based DVR and stream the signal back. The Court found this infringed on the rights of TV broadcasters. Will this impact cloud storage providers who allow users to store music and movies in the cloud?

Answer this Question


3 total
Vote Up (3)

Scotusblog has a great, easy to understand summary of the decision if you are interested. http://www.scotusblog.com/2014/06/how-copyright-law-blocks-cheap-interne...

Vote Up (2)

I’ve read an article or two saying this puts cloud computing providers at risk, but I’m not sure that the decision actually does that. I haven’t read the entire decision, but Justice Breyer, who is generally considered the most tech savvy member of the Supreme Court goes out of his way to limit the holding to the facts in the Aereo case. He even explicitly says that the decision does not apply to cloud computing in general.


Even granting that, however, it is common for decisions to open up a can of unintended worms. I wouldn’t be surprised if there are attempts to use expansive readings to apply the Aereo case to other cloud computing disputes. This decision seems to put a lot of emphasis on the fact the Aereo “contemporaneously streams” video content. I think this is an attempt to differentiate what Aereo was doing from people storing content in the cloud. Whether it is sufficient, only time will tell. 

Vote Up (2)

It might if the other companies are using the same business model as Aereo. It probably won't if they aren't, so it really depends on the company's business practices.

Ask a question

Join Now or Sign In to ask a question.
Oracle chairman Larry Ellison has delivered another dose of hype for the vendor's cloud platform, but many customers may need more convincing before they make the leap.
Earlier this month, Microsoft quietly appointed software architect Mark Russinovich as chief technology officer for its Azure cloud computing platform, formalizing a role he's been executing for the past several years.
Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella wooed India's government and banks on Tuesday with an offer to host cloud services including Azure and Office 365 in the country.
New technology may soon allow you to control your phone without touching or talking to it
Aiming to make cloud computing and DevOps training more accessible to women, Intel is sponsoring the IC3 Cloud Scholars program.
A hybrid cloud delivers IT efficiencies, and proprietary business intelligence tools, to help hundreds of hotel owners boost profitability.
Oracle needs to recognize that the consumerization of IT is already here.
Cisco on Monday said it is expanding on its Intercloud multi-cloud service provider initiative with another $1 billion investment, designed to lead to more products, data centers and partners.
Rackspace is in the process of rebooting a substantial portion of its cloud servers before Oct. 1.

White Papers & Webcasts

See more White Papers | Webcasts

Join us: