What does it mean to developers if Oracle wins on its argument that APIs are copyrightable?


In the first portion of the Google/Oracle trial, Oracle is arguing that Google used APIs that are copyrighted by Oracle (or were copyrighted by Sun). I've always thought that as long as you didn't straight up copy the software, you could reproduce an API's interface. In fact, you kinda have to. If Oracle's position is accepted as "The Law", isn't this going to be a big issue for many, many developers?

Answer this Question


2 total
Vote Up (11)

I suspect it will inspire many developers to avoid making the same choices as Google. Heh. We'll have to wait and see how it turns out though. You just never know how the courts are going to deal with these kinds of things. It may yet turn out in Google's favor. We'll see.

Vote Up (9)

It could have far reaching impact.  Linux programers might want to think about writing code and using POSIX APIs.   How do you deal with it if you can't use those APIs?  Dunno.  And one example of unintended consequences that I've heard used is that this raises the question whether IBM could claim SQL and HTML because they grew out of IBM's work.  


The partial verdict that was reached still leaves us guessing.  Essentially, the jury said, yeah Google took Oracle/Sun Java code, but then they didn't decide whether that was permissible or not.  Without answering that question, I don't see how any conclusion can be reached. 

Ask a question

Join Now or Sign In to ask a question.
The enterprise mainstay has proved resilient in the face of many challenges -- but just how long can it remain a top programming language?
The show will focus on hardware, like the old one, but with a twist for modern times.
While administrators scramble to fix the newly discovered Shellshock vulnerability, Harvard University researchers are putting the finishing touches on a scripting language built to mitigate the damage caused by such holes.
At least not until a few months after the device launches.
New job listing data shows that demand for Python developers is up significantly
A new study finds that scripting languages have a performance edge in completing everyday tasks
At a time when Web and mobile technology development have become top priorities, effective enterprise architecture matters more than ever. Here are this year's six winning initiatives
Journalists, nurses and plumbers are among those who drink more coffee than people in technology
A new study of GitHub data reveals characteristics of successful open source projects
Wyvern securely rolls five programming languages into one.

White Papers & Webcasts

See more White Papers | Webcasts

Join us: