Should the “right to be forgotten” be an actual right for all people worldwide?

hughye

The EU has forced Google to remove search results for people if they request it. I’m a fairly private person, so in some ways it appeals to me. However, this seems awfully close to censorship to me, and I’m not sure I like the idea of people being able to remove things they don’t like by force of law. What do other people think? Should the right to be forgotten be a basic right for all internet users, or is it a bridge too far?

Topic: Government
Answer this Question

Answers

1 total
sspade
Vote Up (3)

I think that you leave an important factor - the truth of the link does not matter. What we have seen in the EU is that many of the people who want to be removed from search results are people who have done bad things in the past, often actual criminal behavior. I have a problem with people being able to hide their crimes from other people. Frankly, I think that’s part of the punishment if you commit a crime and are convicted of it - other people get to know. On the other hand, if you are accused of a crime and then exonerated, I can easily see a valid reason for wanted that not to show up in search results. 

 

I personally would have to think this through, and I don’t think enough thought was given to this policy by regulators before it was implemented. While I do think there are valid reasons for wanting to "be forgotten, an exception to the “right to be forgotten” should be carved out when someone is trying to conceal their past wrongdoing. Just imagine Bernie Madoff was out of jail and was offering you a “great” investment opportunity. You go search for him and it turns up nothing negative. Whose rights are being protected in that example? As it currently exists in the EU, the right to be forgotten can also be the right to deceive others about oneself. 

Ask a question

Join Now or Sign In to ask a question.
The U.S. Federal Communications Commission should abandon its efforts to pass net neutrality rules because new regulations would hurt investment and the deployment of broadband, a parade of Republican senators and advocates said Wednesday.
European government agencies should adopt open document formats in their dealings with citizens, outgoing European Commissioner for the Digital Agenda Neelie Kroes has urged.
The U.S. Congress is unlikely to pass legislation to end the National Security Agency's widespread collection of U.S. telephone records before leaving Washington, D.C., on a two-month break.
The U.S. Federal Communications Commission's deadline for the public to comment on the agency's proposed net neutrality rules passed Monday with more than 3 million comments filed, by far a record number for an FCC proceeding.
Google fielded 19 percent more requests from the U.S. government for data on its users in the first half of this year compared to the second half of last year, the company said Monday.
The collection and analysis of big data holds great promise, but may also lead some companies to create profiles of consumers leading to discrimination, the chairwoman of the U.S. Federal Trade Commission said Monday.
Google is planning to test Internet delivery by drone high above New Mexico, according to a government filing.
The Defense Information Systems Agency's David Bennett calls the cloud 'viable' for certain government operations.
Swedish law requiring network operators to retain communications metadata continues to breach European Union rules, according to Swedish ISP Bahnhof, which has asked the European Commission to intervene.
The U.S. government once threatened to fine Yahoo US$250,000 a day if it failed to assist with its surveillance efforts, Yahoo said Thursday.
Join us:
Facebook

Twitter

Pinterest

Tumblr

LinkedIn

Google+

randomness