Are third-party replacement batteries for laptops as good as OEMs?

jluppino

My personal laptop, a 2-year old Compaq, has a battery that has "gone bad." It won't hold a charge for more than 3-4 minutes, which pretty much makes my laptop a marginal desktop with a crummy keyboard at this point. I was looking at replacement batteries, and I can get some replacements for 50% of what an OEM replacement will cost. Is it worth paying extra for the OEM, or are the after-market replacements just as good?

Topic: Hardware
Answer this Question

Answers

3 total
jimlynch
Vote Up (23)

It really depends on the battery. I recommend doing some google searches for reviews of batteries you might want to use. See what other people's experiences are with them before you buy one. That might help prevent getting stuck with a lemon.

SafeBatteries
Vote Up (20)

Hi jluppino,

 

I work for SafeBatteries.com which specializes in making and selling laptop batteries that perform better than OEM. We currently use only the advanced Panasonic NNP Li-ion cells in all our laptop batteries and these cells are widely considered to be the best performing cell currently made. The offer about %30 more power capacity and should easily last longer than the typical OEM batteries that use the typical standard cells.  

 

A typical 6 cell HP OEM battery rates at 4400mAh or 48Wh of total power capacity and last roughly 400-600 charging cycles until they are completely used up. 

 

The "Max Capacity" brand of battery that we make use only the newer Panasonic NNP type cells which provides about 30% more power for the same 6 cell laptop battery (5800mAh or 63Wh of total power). As for service life, our battery retains about 60%-70% of its capacity even after 500 charging cycles. This means the cells are considered to be long lasting (3 years or more depending how quickly you go through a charging cycles).

 

All the replacement batteries models we carry use these newer/advanced cells from Panasonic and have an average selling price around ~$75 for a 6 cell and $109 for extended.

 

Please feel free to let us know what you think, or if we can provide more details about us vs. other laptop batteries.  

 

Regards,

 

John from SafeBatteries.com (A US based company)

dvarian
Vote Up (20)

It really varies. I wish I could give a better answer. Some are absolute trash; I've seen new replacement batteries that wouldn't hold a charge, and the output was below specs. On the other hand, I've seen replacements that were just as good as OEM. It really varies by manufacturer. If you get a cheap, generic Chinese replacement, it could go either way. Buy something from a reputable battery manufacturer (it could even be the company that made it for Compaq), and you will probably be just as satisfied with the result as you would with OEM replacement. Lenmar batteries are widely available and usually ok, but they may vary by model - I don't have a large of enough sample to endorse them with confidence.

Ask a question

Join Now or Sign In to ask a question.
Google has partnered with scientists at the University of California, Santa Barbara to build new processors for use in quantum computing systems.
Consulting and technology firm, Oakton, has unveiled the results of a survey it has had commissioned with clients on their current and future ERP implementation plans. And the conclusions that can be drawn from it aren't pretty.
U.S. data centers use more electricity than they need, a new report finds, and IT managers are too cautious about managing power and businesses are unwilling to invest in energy conservation.
Imagination Technologies hopes to catch up with ARM and Intel in the mobile space with its first MIPS 64-bit processor core design, which could be in tablets and smartphones by 2016.
Advanced Micro Devices is targeting mid-range desktops with its latest high-end FX chips based on the Piledriver architecture.
Also a few notes from Sony's pre-Tokyo Game Show press conference.
Intel is shipping its fastest PC processor to date and its first with eight cores.
Tablet shipments worldwide will continue to grow this year, but not as quickly as previously expected, according to a forecast released Friday.
Although forecasts for PC shipments have brightened, much of the improvement stems from bets that Chromebooks and Macs will make up a larger part of this year's market.
Leap Motion may have a new lease on life thanks to inexpensive virtual reality headsets like the Oculus Rift.
Join us:
Facebook

Twitter

Pinterest

Tumblr

LinkedIn

Google+