What is the fastest external hard drive connection you can get?

mgrater

Firewire, USB, or another?

Topic: Hardware
Answer this Question

Answers

7 total
jfruh
Vote Up (45)

Steven Vaughn-Nichols wrote an article for ITworld comparing USB 3 and eSata.  About a year old at this point but you hopefully will still find it useful.

 

 

ka_clinart
Vote Up (40)

In the age of cloud computing external hard drives are probably going the way of the 3.5" floppy, but in answer to your question, Firewire 800 is still the speed king until USB 3.0 proves otherwise.

al3ph1
Vote Up (40)

Currently, eSATA is fast and has less overhead than the others.  And provided the PC picks it up as a SATA device, it also will do S.M.A.R.T.

 

http://www.newertech.com/Static/articles/images/macensteineSATA_6.jpg

 

USB 3.0 changes all this though, but not much in my opinion.  Not enough to declare itself the speed demon victor anyway.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PqlqCoQMLsQ

 

Also, read this article:

http://www.itworld.com/hardware/98987/usb-30-vs-esata-is-faster-better

 

Also, speed is relative to what you'll be doing with it, ie., copying large files vs. small files.  Read vs. writes.  And that will only happen as fast as the slowest link.

 

In general though, eSATA is faster than Firewire 800 and USB 2.0.  USB 3.0 changes things, but just barely.

Vanguard
Vote Up (39)

Intel, in collaboration with Apple, just released the Thunderbolt interface (while under development it was known as LightPeak).  It is a 2-channel bi-directional 10Gbps connection over copper, a huge leap in perfmance over anything else.  An optical interface is under development  for more distance.  It supports data transfer as well as providing input to your video display.
The latest MacBook Pro and iMac systems now include this latest and greatest change, and Apple will remove Firewire ports eventually.  The connector used is the mini-DisplayPort connector, part of Apple's contribution to this new "Standard".   It looks like the first external SSD drive to support Thunderbolt will be from LaCie this summer.  Wintel systems and more peripherals to support Thunderbolt are sure to follow.

jimlynch
Vote Up (36)

Hi mgrater,

PCMag had a buying guide about how to buy an external hard disk. You might find it helpful:

http://www.pcmag.com/article2/0,2817,2358135,00.asp#fbid=TnX_w8LfYIg

sandeepseeram
Vote Up (35)

USB 3.0 is the fastest if you are connecting a 3.0 or 2.5'' inch hard drive.Never tried thunderbolt on Mac OS... 

 

Sandeep Seeram

 

wstark
Vote Up (35)

Check out the nifty chart on this website:
http://www.lacie.com/us/products/product.htm?id=10549

Thunderbolt is great, but only works with iMacs and MacBooks. Next spring, Intel has promised to deliver Thunderbolt support with the Ivybridge chipset. Until then, you're probably better off using USB3, since USB3 cards are relatively inexpensive and USB2 devices gain a speed bonus when connecting upstream to USB3.

Ask a question

Join Now or Sign In to ask a question.
Oracle is the latest in a string of firms getting a custom fit instead of off the shelf.
Be sure to show your sysadmin how much you appreciate him or her today - but keep it sane
The expected boom in demand for small, often isolated devices in the Internet of Things is driving developers to craft new types of components.
The U.S. State Department's main computer system for processing passport and visa applications crashed earlier this week leading to global delays for travel documents.
The first third-party servers licensed to use IBM's Power architecture will be on the market early next year.
A new model of the Raspberry Pi is out, but it's not Raspberry Pi 2
When the goal is to deploy computers in mass quantities to keep employees productive, nothing beats an ultra-slim desktop computer. Here are four options for enterprises looking for computers that pack a punch but don't take up much space on a desk, shelf or table.
Apple's grip on the tablet is loosening, with the iPad losing ground during the second quarter this year to Android and Windows tablets.
China's anti-monopoly investigation of Qualcomm is starting to disrupt its licensing business and making it harder for the U.S. company to collect royalties from the country.
Low-cost Android tablets with 64-bit processors and 4K video decoding capabilities could be around the corner, thanks to Allwinner's plan to ship its first 64-bit ARM processor by year end.
Join us:
Facebook

Twitter

Pinterest

Tumblr

LinkedIn

Google+

randomness