Do you think Google's decision to link Google+ account IDs with Play comments is a good one?

kreiley

I'm down with encouraging a modicum of civility on the internet. Totally. And there are quite a few post in the comments of Google Play that I would consider inappropriate for public discourse. Google's answer is to link users Google+ with Google Play, so that comments show their user identity and photo. I'm a little conflicted on this. While I support civility, I don't necessarily want my identity publicly linked directly with apps that I use, and it makes me less likely to comment. At the same time, what else can Google do to encourage people to act like decent human beings? I just don't like the feeling that there is a constant chipping away at my privacy and relative anonymity. How do other people feel about this? Did Google make the right call?

Topic: Internet
Answer this Question

Answers

3 total
ttopp
Vote Up (14)

I'm ok with it.  It may be another little chip away at online privacy, but you don't have to post a review.  I'm as foul mouthed as the next guy in the proper context, maybe more so, but user reviews aren't the place for abusive, profane speech.  If it helps raise the level of discourse even a little I think it is a good thing overall.  And let's face it, seeing "Jane Smith" and her cat avatar doesn't mean anything to me - not that I have anything against cat avatars! :-)  It's like looking in a phone book, all those names are just names unless I know them.   

Christopher Nerney
Vote Up (12)

I'm also conflicted. Basically it comes down to what you value more -- civility or privacy. I value both, but I rank privacy higher. You can choose not to enter areas of the Internet where bad behavior rules -- or at least try to avoid them as best you can -- but it's hard to un-ring the privacy bell. Once your privacy is exposed, it's hard to regain it.

prospero
Vote Up (10)

Yes, I think.

no need to register in all the websites and everywhere you with all information

Ask a question

Join Now or Sign In to ask a question.
A federal appeals court has cleared Yelp of claims that it extorted businesses into advertising on its site by fabricating bad reviews about them.
Mobile computing, OpenStack and containers win, NSX, vCloud Air details too thin at VMware show.
Consulting and technology firm, Oakton, has unveiled the results of a survey it has had commissioned with clients on their current and future ERP implementation plans. And the conclusions that can be drawn from it aren't pretty.
The rebrand reflects a sea change change in how companies buy IT products.
If photos were stolen during a cloud hack, enterprises may be more skittish over cloud use.
Uber Technologies must stop operating its ride sharing service UberPop in Germany or pay a fine, a German court has ruled -- but the ban could be short lived, a court spokesman said Tuesday.
When not busy helping to find new treatments for cancer, IBM Watson is helping to cook up a few new dishes as well.
Facebook is testing a way to let users of its mobile app search for posts shared with them in the past.
Thanks to the cloud, the “as a service” trend is getting a little out of control
Baidu and Tencent are teaming up with a Chinese shopping mall operator in a joint venture that could steal business away from local e-commerce giant Alibaba Group.
Join us:
Facebook

Twitter

Pinterest

Tumblr

LinkedIn

Google+