Should lawyers be allowed to search all your computers for P2P lawsuits?


A lawyer in a P2P file-sharing case now admits that since an IP address only ties a particular router in a home to the names of files that the media industry says were downloaded illegally, the police should search every computer in the home until they find the offending computer and/or user.  Is this feasible? Is this reasonable? What gives the RIAA and MPAA the right to barge into our homes and businesses to spy on our computers?

Tags: lawsuit, MPAA, P2P, RIAA
Topic: Internet
Answer this Question


2 total
Vote Up (12)

While we don't ban users from installing P2P software on their laptops, we have our desktops locked down pretty hard. Users know that they're not supposed to engage in non-work behavior during the workday, and pretty much they all comply. As far as allowing lawyers or police or BSA investigators, they'll need to have a warrant. Since our company is responsible for how our computers are used, we take this pretty seriously. And as far as file-sharing is concerned, I haven't seen that much of it since Napster died and the tools that followed were mostly virus-havens.

Vote Up (8)

It's a really stupid idea. Do they think the cops have nothing better to do than run around searching computers? And how many law enforcement (especially local ones) organizations have the expertise to do that in the first place?

I think it's a case of the RIAA and MPAA folks trying to scare as many people as possible. It sort of makes sense in a weird way from their perspective. But I just can't see police having the time or personnel to do this in a comprehensive way.

The cops have WAY too many other issues and criminals to deal with day in and day out. So I doubt that this would really happen in a way that would impact a lot of users. It just doesn't make any real sense.

Ask a question

Join Now or Sign In to ask a question.
Rhapsody International, which operates the Rhapsody and Napster music services, said Tuesday it plans to expand in France and Latin America as a result of deals with mobile operators SRF and Telefonica.
A configuration problem in Facebook's popular Instagram application for Apple devices could allow a hacker to hijack a person's account if they're both on the same public Wi-Fi network.
A network testbed being constructed just south of San Francisco will help carriers and vendors develop standards for better cloud services, the CloudEthernet Forum says.
If you like to send messages via Facebook when you're on the move, get ready to download a new app.
Facebook earlier this summer sparked criticism over a study in which it manipulated the feeds of some of its users, but the dating site OkCupid says what Facebook did is normal, and that in fact it has run its own user-behavior tests.
Social networking sites in China that are modeled on Facebook are having a hard time holding on to users, with customers like Beijing resident Shi Yunfeng, drifting away to newer services.
Financial institutions use many technologies to fight crime, but much of the work comes too late, focusing on suspicious activity, like uncharacteristic charges or money transfers, after it happens.
California is moving its IT services to a cloud, on-demand, subscription-based service that state officials believe may meet as much as 80% of its computing needs.
The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission has dropped its investigation into disclosures about Facebook advertising sales before the company went public in 2012.
A method for tracking users across the Internet called "canvas fingerprinting" is simple to stop, but average Internet users may not know how to do it.
Join us: