What's the problem with Google+ factoring into Google search results?

TheCount

So google search results have incorporated an option to factor in what you and your friends have +ed using your Google+ profile. Some articles are claiming that this has broken Google search, twitter is freaking out, and there are news stories all over tech sites. Frankly, I don't see the harm in this. What are people getting so bent out of shape about?

Topic: Internet
Answer this Question

Answers

3 total
jlister
Vote Up (7)

Some people are concerned that this is an example of Google using its dominant search engine status to push consumers into Google+.  I'm not buying this; if I care what search results my friends "+1ed" I'll ask them, it isn't enough to push me to Google+.  I do use Google+ already, and I don't see this being a huge mover of people.  A related complaint is that Google is not utilizing similar search results/info from Facebook and Twitter, so that it is essentially an anti-trust issue.  I'm not convinced on this point either.  Google has attempted to use results from both of those companies in the past, and they both refused Google's offer.  So now they are upset when Google uses it's own social media to drive search results.  That seems a little like a kid not wanting to share his toy, then throwing a tantrum when he sees another kid playing with his own Stretch Armstrong.  I do agree with wolfkin_'s point about the default setting including Google+ driven results, which requires users to opt-out instead of requiring them to opt-in.  At the moment the opt-out is very easy, with a button at the top of the search results page, and hopefully Google will never go the way of Facebook and hide settings in a confusing menu of account settings.   

jimlynch
Vote Up (10)

Well, the good thing is that there are other search engines. Linux Mint incorporates Duck Duck Go and you might want to give it a shot instead of Google. Google still has huge market share right now in search, but that doesn't mean it will go on forever.

http://duckduckgo.com/

"DuckDuckGo is a general purpose
search engine like Google or Bing.
• Get way more instant answers
Zero-click info above the links (red box).
• Less spam and clutter
We ban those useless sites with just ads.
• Lots and lots of goodies
Special searches (tech), syntax & settings.
• Real privacy
We don't track you! (Illustrated guide.)"

Vote Up (7)

Far as i can tell it's basic slipperly slope stuff.

 

That is noone cares about giving us the option to factor in the google+ stuff but from there it's one slighty change then then that becomes default and then Google is deciding what you can and can't see in your search results.. which is arguably bad.

Ask a question

Join Now or Sign In to ask a question.
Judging from the number of people poring over their smartphones on the sidewalk, in their cars and in public places, mobile seems to have stolen our attention away from the wired Internet and traditional TV.
Google has reportedly launched an expansive effort to bring wireless networks and affordable computing to emerging markets such as sub-Saharan Africa and Southeast Asia, moves that could bring the Internet to a further billion people.
The U.S. Federal Trade Commission has reportedly launched an investigation into Google's display ad business amid complaints from rivals that the company is abusing its power in how it sells online-graphical and video ads.
The Apple CEO insists that his company doesn’t dodge taxes, but instructions to his personal assistant may suggest otherwise
Yahoo has acquired PlayerScale, a startup developer of infrastructure software for cross-platform gaming, adding to its string of recent acquisitions.
Manuel Araoz, a 23-year-old developer in Argentina, has an idea for Bitcoin that doesn't focus on money.
Users in the U.K. and France will have to wait a bit longer to get their hands on the HTC First. The first smartphone to come preinstalled with Facebook Home has been delayed in those countries while Facebook updates the software to address some negative user feedback.
Deploying an update of its DB2 database, IBM is pitching its SmartCloud infrastructure as a service (IaaS) for use in data reporting and analysis.
Box has acquired an unreleased application called Folders, designed to give iPhone and iPad users a mobile front-end interface for the cloud storage and file management and sharing service as well as for competitors Google Drive and Dropbox.
Lyft, the ridesharing service known for its fleet of pink mustache-festooned cars, is eyeing international expansion supported by its biggest funding round yet.
Join us:
Facebook

Twitter

Pinterest

Tumblr

LinkedIn

Google+