What's the problem with Google+ factoring into Google search results?

TheCount

So google search results have incorporated an option to factor in what you and your friends have +ed using your Google+ profile. Some articles are claiming that this has broken Google search, twitter is freaking out, and there are news stories all over tech sites. Frankly, I don't see the harm in this. What are people getting so bent out of shape about?

Topic: Internet
Answer this Question

Answers

3 total
jimlynch
Vote Up (23)

Well, the good thing is that there are other search engines. Linux Mint incorporates Duck Duck Go and you might want to give it a shot instead of Google. Google still has huge market share right now in search, but that doesn't mean it will go on forever.

http://duckduckgo.com/

"DuckDuckGo is a general purpose
search engine like Google or Bing.
• Get way more instant answers
Zero-click info above the links (red box).
• Less spam and clutter
We ban those useless sites with just ads.
• Lots and lots of goodies
Special searches (tech), syntax & settings.
• Real privacy
We don't track you! (Illustrated guide.)"

jlister
Vote Up (19)

Some people are concerned that this is an example of Google using its dominant search engine status to push consumers into Google+.  I'm not buying this; if I care what search results my friends "+1ed" I'll ask them, it isn't enough to push me to Google+.  I do use Google+ already, and I don't see this being a huge mover of people.  A related complaint is that Google is not utilizing similar search results/info from Facebook and Twitter, so that it is essentially an anti-trust issue.  I'm not convinced on this point either.  Google has attempted to use results from both of those companies in the past, and they both refused Google's offer.  So now they are upset when Google uses it's own social media to drive search results.  That seems a little like a kid not wanting to share his toy, then throwing a tantrum when he sees another kid playing with his own Stretch Armstrong.  I do agree with wolfkin_'s point about the default setting including Google+ driven results, which requires users to opt-out instead of requiring them to opt-in.  At the moment the opt-out is very easy, with a button at the top of the search results page, and hopefully Google will never go the way of Facebook and hide settings in a confusing menu of account settings.   

Vote Up (18)

Far as i can tell it's basic slipperly slope stuff.

 

That is noone cares about giving us the option to factor in the google+ stuff but from there it's one slighty change then then that becomes default and then Google is deciding what you can and can't see in your search results.. which is arguably bad.

Ask a question

Join Now or Sign In to ask a question.
A network testbed being constructed just south of San Francisco will help carriers and vendors develop standards for better cloud services, the CloudEthernet Forum says.
If you like to send messages via Facebook when you're on the move, get ready to download a new app.
Facebook earlier this summer sparked criticism over a study in which it manipulated the feeds of some of its users, but the dating site OkCupid says what Facebook did is normal, and that in fact it has run its own user-behavior tests.
Social networking sites in China that are modeled on Facebook are having a hard time holding on to users, with customers like Beijing resident Shi Yunfeng, drifting away to newer services.
Financial institutions use many technologies to fight crime, but much of the work comes too late, focusing on suspicious activity, like uncharacteristic charges or money transfers, after it happens.
California is moving its IT services to a cloud, on-demand, subscription-based service that state officials believe may meet as much as 80% of its computing needs.
The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission has dropped its investigation into disclosures about Facebook advertising sales before the company went public in 2012.
A method for tracking users across the Internet called "canvas fingerprinting" is simple to stop, but average Internet users may not know how to do it.
Chinese search giant Baidu reported a 34 percent jump in profit for the second quarter, with mobile ad sales accounting for almost a third of revenue for the first time.
The expected boom in demand for small, often isolated devices in the Internet of Things is driving developers to craft new types of components.
randomness