What impact will congressional opposition have on to FCC efforts to enforce net neutrality?


The FCC said that it wants to reclassify ISPs as common carriers so that it can enforce net neutrality rules. There is intense opposition to net neutrality by some in Congress, to the point that during the Federal Government shutdown a couple of months ago, some Congressmen demanded an end to net neutrality as a condition to funding the government. Can the FCC do anything to reestablish net neutrality in the face of this, or do we just have to accept that it is ended?

Topic: Legal
Answer this Question


3 total
Vote Up (9)

Well, to be fair, it’s not “some in Congress” it is Republicans in the House, although I’m shocked that they found the time to even mention net neutrality in between all the votes to defund Obamacare. The FCC can take many actions without explicit approval from Congress based on existing laws. The problem, if you are a supporter of net neutrality, is that Congress controls the purse strings, and they can act to defund or restrict sections of the FCC that are attempting to implement the changes.


It really comes down to a fundamental difference in philosophy (once you get past the millions of dollars of donations from ISPs). One side thinks that preventing a business from having too much power over consumers is a good thing, and the other thinks there shouldn’t be any control over businesses’ actions, because “the marketplace” will sort it out in the most efficient way possible. I personally think the later view is simplistic, while I’m sure those who worship at the temple of “the marketplace” think I am a socialist commie fascist. I suppose the good thing about a divided government is that neither side will completely get what they want. Of course, we used to accomplish that through the art of compromise, but with compromise now being considered almost an act of treason by many primary voters, we have to take what we can get. I personally hope that means a preservation of net neutrality.  

Vote Up (6)

It's hard to say right now. The 2014 election is coming up, and we have a very different congress after it happens. In the short term we probably won't see any changes, but over the longer term things could change drastically depending on who is elected in the next congress.

Vote Up (5)

Legislation just introduced to restore net neutrality, but I would be shocked if anything actually gets passed, or even voted on, by this Congress. Anyway, it’s called the Open Internet Preservation Act, so you might want to give your Senators and Congressman a call if it’s something you support.


Ask a question

Join Now or Sign In to ask a question.
An electronic case-handling dashboard and a network of specialists will be created to help EU data protection authorities deal with complaints filed by people whose requests to delete search results based on a recent "right-to-be-forgotten" ruling is denied.
Storing someone's private information in a crime database for 20 years when charges against that person have been dropped violates privacy rights, the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) ruled Thursday.
With the release of its new mobile operating system on Wednesday, Apple has become the first smartphone maker to enable by default a kill switch that can lock and secure a stolen phone.
Yelp has agreed to pay US$450,000 to the U.S. Federal Trade Commission to settle charges that the company accepted registrations to its services from children under 13 through its apps.
Lyft is bringing its car-pooling service to Los Angeles, even while California regulators say it's illegal.
Customers cringe every time they hear about a bank, retail or healthcare hack that puts personal or financial data at risk. Today's hackers are after much more that credit card numbers, though -- and most firms are powerless to stop them.
A U.S. appeals court has thrown out a US$368.2 million award against Apple in a patent infringement case brought by patent-holding and software company VirnetX.
The Frankfurt Regional Court has lifted a nationwide preliminary ban on Uber Technologies' ride-sharing service UberPop, ruling that there is no urgent need for an emergency ban.
A subsidiary of Hewlett-Packard has admitted violating the U.S. Foreign Corrupt Practices Act by bribing Russian officials to win a contract with the Office of the Prosecutor General of the Russian Federation.
Microsoft is speaking out publicly to push African government officials to step up efforts to halt the influx of cheap, counterfeit handsets coming into the region from Asia.
Join us: