What would you decide if you were on the jury in Apple v. Samsung?

rousseau

The jury is out, and soon we will get to see how this long saga turns out. I have my guess on how it will turn out, but it is such a complex area of law and there are so many issues to be decided that it is fair to say that your guess is a good as mine. What would you decide if you were sitting on the jury? Do you think Apple or Samsung should prevail?

Topic: Legal
Answer this Question

Answers

2 total
hughye
Vote Up (14)

I don't give Apple full credit for creating the smartphone, I just give them credit for refining it and giving it the current form factor with touch screen.  Much of the basic idea was fleshed out by Palm in the 90s, including a touch interface, and the Palm Treo 600 had similar basic capabilities to an iPhone in 2003, and included a colour screen. There were other predecessor wireless devices prior to the iPhone's release, although none offered everything that the original iPhone did.  Nokia made the 9110 Communicator in 1998, for example, which had a nice keyboard as well as wireless connectivity.  Poor old RIM came out with the BlackBerry 5810 in 2002, which had voice calling, calendar functions, email and internet connectivity AND a keyboard, with the same basic shape that continues with BlackBerries to this day.  To carry it further, Arcus was making rectangular tablets long before Apple, so if Samsung copied Apple, how did Apple not copy Arcus?  Dunno.  

 

Sure, Apple put all the pieces together into a slick package that actually worked quite well, but it didn't really invent the concept, it just took preexisting concept and integrated them into a brilliant product with multiple application available.  Unless Apple proves that Samsung copied something other than the rectangular shape (I'm being a bit glib, but I stand by the basic point), Apple shouldn't prevail in my opinion.  Invention is generally the aggregation and refinement of what has come before, and I would make the bar quite high to find that Samsung copied the iPhone - it uses a different OS, it has different applications and different specifications.  Sharing a basic shape and concept isn't enough for me to find in Apple's favor.    

jimlynch
Vote Up (14)

I'd rule in favor of Apple, hands down. Samsung clearly stole design ideas from them. If Samsung does not lose then what is the point of all the relevant laws? It will mean that any company can simply steal and copy the ideas and designs of another company with impunity. Why bother to even try to be innovative when someone else will steal it from you?

Samsung must lose this case.

Ask a question

Join Now or Sign In to ask a question.
Google is going to tour Europe with a band of external advisers this fall to discuss a landmark ruling by Europe's top court that gave people the right to have personal information excluded from search engine listings in Europe.
MonkeyParking, an app that lets people bid on public parking spaces, said Thursday it will suspend its service in San Francisco to avoid a potential lawsuit from the city attorney.
One-third of Infosys worksites have 100% Asian workers, lawsuit alleges.
Police from eight countries together with several private security companies disrupted the online infrastructure used by cybercriminals to control computers infected with a malware program called Shylock.
Amazon.com has billed parents for millions of dollars' worth of unauthorized in-app purchases made by their children, the FTC said in a complaint filed Thursday in a U.S. court.
Several Facebook and WhatsApp competitors were sent questionnaires by the European Commission asking them about the effect that the US$19 billion deal between the companies could have on competition, people familiar with the matter have confirmed.
Google, Dropbox and a few other high-tech firms have come up with a new way to help defend themselves against patent trolls.
The operator of a Tor server used by someone to download a pornographic image of a minor has been given a three-month suspended prison sentence by an Austrian court for abetting access to pornographic images of minors.
Two high-profile Silicon Valley lawsuits have been thrown bizarre twists in the past week after individuals, apparently in one case including incarcerated murderers, attempted to join the legal actions.
NetSuite has been hit with another customer lawsuit, this time from textile products manufacturer Kentwool, which alleges the cloud ERP vendor pulled the wool over its eyes in order to take its money.
Join us:
Facebook

Twitter

Pinterest

Tumblr

LinkedIn

Google+