How can wireless carriers detect if you are tethering your device?

wstark

First off, I understand that, depending on the user agreement, using your device as a wireless hotspot can violate the terms of service. Setting aside the question of how fair it is to have to pay an additional charge to use the amount of data that you are already paying for (hmmm, not sure I sounded all that neutral there), how can carriers tell if you are tethering your device? Why would they really care anyway? If you go over your data plan limits they either charge you a hefty overage or throttle your speeds to a crawl, so I'm not sure what they lose if their customers are tethering anyway.

Answer this Question

Answers

2 total
Christopher Nerney
Vote Up (23)

Based on some research I did for an article about a carrier using data analytics to examine traffic and usage patterns, the carriers can tell which apps are accessing their networks. That includes tethering apps, of course.

The reason carriers care is because they want to charge customers for their own tethering services. But last summer, Verizon Wireless and the Federal Communications Commission reached a settlement that allows Verizon customers to use their smartphones as wi-fi hotspots for other devices at no extra cost. Tethering is now included in Verizon's base wireless plan.

jhotz
Vote Up (18)

AT&T seems to be the most aggressive about looking for tethering, and are quick to detect it.  I'm not an AT&T customer, but my carrier charges extra if you want to use your device as a hotspot, and removed the function from the phone.  Soooooo, I rooted my phone, sideloaded an app that enables it to work as a WiFi hotspot and uses a proxy server to keep it somewhat on the "down low" and only use it on the rare occasion when I am away from WiFi and really need to get online with my laptop.  I probably end up needing to use it once every 2 or 3 months and stay well under my data limit, so my carrier either hasn't turned its all seeing eye upon me, or that little amount doesn't bother them.  I'll take the chance, although I'm sure that they would prefer I pay them $30 a month extra instead.    

 

If a carrier really is looking, I think that they will pick it up, often through TLL values or the APNs that tethered data traffic uses.  Like Christopher Nerney pointed out, it isn't as if the carriers are new to data analytics.  It's just a little unclear exactly what raises the red flag.  

 

The Verizon thing was somehow related to the specific spectrum used or something (I can't remember without looking it up), and it doesn't apply to other carriers.  So if you aren't a Verizon customer and you are tether, you are still a bad boy who plays by his own rules.  And probably violates your TOS, which I might feel bad about if the carriers didn't constantly change the TOS to be as beneficial as possible to them.        

Ask a question

Join Now or Sign In to ask a question.
The right to unlock your cellphone became law on Friday as President Barack Obama signed a bill that rapidly passed both houses of the U.S. Congress.
Suspicious job postings on LinkedIn leave many wondering if Nokia is preparing to reenter the Android phone market. Plus: Amazon gives away 30 free Android apps, and check out the gorgeous Android smartwatch engineered by Hewlett-Packard.
Best Buy's CEO says PC sales are recovering as tablets "crash."
French carrier Iliad's surprise unsolicited bid for T-Mobile US may be good news for everyone but Sprint.
The Qi wireless charging spec added a resonance extension to its existing induction spec, meaning enabled mobile devices can be charged more than an inch away from the pad.
The U.S. Federal Trade Commission failed to adequately consider the consumer benefits of easy in-app purchases in its recent complaints accusing Apple and Amazon.com of allowing children to buy digital products without parental permission, according to some critics of the agency.
French mobile operator Iliad has offered to buy T-Mobile US, the fourth-largest U.S. cellular carrier, in a bid that could complicated an offer reportedly in the works at Sprint.
Facebook introduced an app on Thursday that will give mobile phone subscribers in Zambia access to a set of free basic mobile data services -- and Facebook.
FCC Chairman Tom Wheeler has sharply questioned Verizon Wireless over its plan announced last week to throttle mobile data speeds for customers with unlimited plans.
Mobile carriers have pulled in hundreds of millions in profits through third-party charges tacked onto customers' bills without their consent, according to a report from a U.S. Senate committee.
Join us:
Facebook

Twitter

Pinterest

Tumblr

LinkedIn

Google+