What is the difference between GSM networks and CDMA networks from a user perspective?

pcaulfield

I know that there is a difference in GSM and CDMA, the two types of networks wireless providers use. An earlier question regarding travel raised my curiosity about this, since I have to make sure that I take a GSM phone with me on trips to Europe, or else it won't work (or at least that is what I have been told, though I have not put this to the test). I also know that GSM devices allow switching of SIM cards for greater portability, whereas CDMA devices pretty much lock you into whatever carrier provided the device. Are there differences beyond those that make one superior to the other, or are they more analogous to different flavors of ice cream, where one isn't really better than the next.

Except chocolate. :-]

Answer this Question

Answers

3 total
jimlynch
Vote Up (23)

I don't think it matters too much to the individual user, beyond making sure they have a phone that works in Europe, etc. For the user a phone is a phone is a phone. You use it to make calls, run applications, do work, whatever, etc.

Perhaps the best possible solution is a phone that runs on both kinds of networks. This would make it exceptionally easy for the user if they are traveling. They wouldn't need to really care which network they had access to since their phone could use either kind.

I could swear I read something about Apple doing something like that in the next iPhone, but I cannot remember where I saw it. It may have only been a rumor, but I like anything that makes it easy and simple for the user.

dblacharski
Vote Up (17)

If you want to stay with a particular company, you are latched to one or the other. AT&T and T-Mobile use GSM, which helps explain the interest in a merger, while Verizon and Sprint use CDMA. Incidentially, although GSM devices do use SIM cards and thus should be portable from carrier to carrier, the reality is that many GSM devices are still locked to one carrier, so that benefit isn't a significant as it should be. As you noted there is a wider global use of GSM technology, which stands for, ahem, Global System for Mobile communication. So if you are traveling internationally, GSM is the way to go.

Other than that, most people won't notice many differences. CDMA phones drop calls a little less often because of differences in the way calls are handed off from tower to tower. The main thing I suggest looking at is coverage where you live and work, and not worry about it unless you intend to take the device with you on international trips.

Apachebianco
Vote Up (14)

Besides the fact that GSM phones use SIM cards, the main difference is that CDMA uses a wider spectrum than GSM, which is good in the sense that there is more coverage but worse in terms of quality. Think of it in terms of radio frequencies with CDMA being AM radio and GSM being FM. You can get AM stations pretty much anywhere but you won't get the quality stereo sound of FM.

Ask a question

Join Now or Sign In to ask a question.
Facebook is testing a way to let users of its mobile app search for posts shared with them in the past.
Samsung has partnered with Nokia to bring navigation service Here to its new smartwatch and Galaxy Android phones.
Thanks to the cloud, the “as a service” trend is getting a little out of control
Baidu and Tencent are teaming up with a Chinese shopping mall operator in a joint venture that could steal business away from local e-commerce giant Alibaba Group.
It seems like poaching drivers is par for the course in the ride-sharing industry.
Is it crazy to pay $1300 for a Chromebook? Some reflections after a year and a half of living with Google's luxurious Pixel.
Microsoft has consolidated the consumer and enterprise editions of OneDrive under a single Android app, a move it plans to replicate across all the platforms that the cloud storage service runs on.
The EU is investing in IT to help it and its citizens protect themselves from floods.
While SAP has made a big push into mobile software and device management with the acquisition of Sybase and a series of apps, it hasn't made overt moves into the devices market. But this could change down the road, judging from a recently published patent application submitted by SAP.
Apple rumors continue to fly. This time it's the device we're unofficially calling the iWatch, and it'll be here next month, sources say.