What is the best choice for a small company, peer-to-peer network or a dedicated server?


We have about a dozen PCs that are used in a retail/commercial business, a couple are used to check out customers, a couple to schedule service calls and maintain those records, one for bookkeeping, and a few workstations around the building. Would it make more sense to go with a peer-to-peer network (which is the current status quo), or would there be many advantages to switching to a dedicated server?

Topic: Networking
Answer this Question


2 total
Vote Up (9)

If you have limited needs for a network, say for example, you just want to be able to share a printer with all of your machines, then you may be ok with peer-to-peer. It has the advantages of being simple, easy to set up (or no set up at all in your case, since you already have a peer-to-peer network), and you don't need to buy any additional hardware. Beyond that, the advantages fall with having a dedicated server.

The expense isn't that much more, since there is usually no need to have a cutting edge machine for a server. One of your existing machines would probably be sufficient. It will be more reliable and faster, and you won't have that Arrrrrgh! moment when someone shuts down a computer while you are accessing files on their hard drive. It will take a little planning and work to create a network, but not too much, and the benefits will be felt by everyone.

Vote Up (6)

If what you have is working, why bother to change? Unless you can define a set of problems that makes it worthwhile to use a dedicated server, it's best to stick with what's working.

Ask a question

Join Now or Sign In to ask a question.
Users of Google Glass will get to meet and compare their techie headgear this weekend at a spot where appearance is everything.
A Space X Falcon rocket lifted off Friday afternoon for the International Space Station (ISS) from the Cape Canaveral Air Station in Florida.
Although Exadata is Oracle's most popular and mature "engineered system," some customers implementing the database machine are making mistakes that prevent them from getting the most performance out of the expensive product, according to a veteran of many Exadata projects.
Tech workers suing over an alleged no-poaching agreement among Silicon Valley firms are fighting an attempt by defendants to ban evidence that might portray Steve Jobs as a bad guy.
Vendors will tell you that the Internet of Things (IoT) has arrived. We're here to tell you that it hasn't.
Formula One racing and cryptocurrency have nearly nothing in common -- except Suzuka. The home of the Japanese Grand Prix will soon debut Japan's first bitcoin ATM.
The clock may be running out on Mt. Gox, but a consortium of investors still wants to relaunch the failed Bitcoin exchange.
Alibaba's Tmall and Taobao sites already sell everything from clothes and furniture to car tires and medicines. But soon they'll also be offering 3G data and voice call plans as well, the Chinese e-commerce giant said Thursday.
Google did little during its first-quarter earnings report to shush critics who say its Enterprise unit is a second-class citizen in its kingdom.
Five music labels have filed a lawsuit against streaming music service Pandora Music, saying the company is violating state law by refusing to pay labels and artists for its use of recordings made before 1972.

White Papers & Webcasts

See more White Papers | Webcasts

Join us: