What's your opinion on the engineer who just reverse-engineered Skype?


The latest news coming out of Russia is that engineer Efim Bushmanov has reverse-engineered the proprietary Skype protocol, with the goal of making an open source copy; a move that Skype (and no doubt Microsoft) is not too happy about. In an eWeek interview, Bushmanov said a few curious things. First of all, he praised Skype as "well-tested and fine-tuned," and then went on to say that "Open source products cannot match that level of polish." It seems to me that instead of participating in what is usually a lively and active open source community, he is discrediting the very community he is claiming to be a part of with comments like that. Is it true that open source can't match the quality of proprietary products? What can be gained from this reverse-engineering?

Answer this Question


3 total
Vote Up (30)

Open source can most definitely match the quality of proprietary products, and even surpass the quality. Firefox is a perfect example. I think Bushmanov is being disingenuous and trying to downplay his project hoping Microsoft won't sue an "inferior" product. Which is pretty much a bad idea.

Vote Up (23)

It's probably better to develop an alternative without the reverse engineering. That just opens a big can of worms and could complicate things legally. There's also an ethics issue with doing that sort of thing.

So I'd rather see something original developed that is not connected to Skype.

Ask a question

Join Now or Sign In to ask a question.
Increasingly stiff competition in the database market has claimed another victim, as InfiniDB has ceased operations effective immediately with plans to file for bankruptcy.
Find out what systemd is and why it matters to Linux users. Plus: An infographic that explains Debian, and two ancient Linux watches from IBM.
Should Microsoft poach more features from Linux for Windows 9? Plus: Why multiple desktops are still better in Linux than in Windows 9, and the future of Linux gaming might not be a bright one.
Journalists, nurses and plumbers are among those who drink more coffee than people in technology
Is ChromeOS a real threat to the future of desktop Linux? Plus: Is Linux or Windows the best option for your business? And KDE developer Aaron Seigo launches an attack on community managers.
A new study of GitHub data reveals characteristics of successful open source projects
Aiming to eliminate a number of onerous data engineering tasks, MapR today updated its distribution of Hadoop to include Apache Drill 0.5.
Introducing Matrix, a new messaging standard that wants to make IM, VoIP, and video as interoperable and open as email.
Have the Linux Mint developers crossed a line into sexism by choosing a female name again? Plus: A review of PCLinuxOS 2014.08, and is Microsoft copying features from Linux in Windows 9?
Facebook has partnered with several large companies to kick off a new project called TODO that aims to improve the way open source software is developed and consumed.