Is Richard Stallman right when he calls Ubuntu "spyware"?

jluppino

Apparently Richard Stallman, founder of the Free Software Foundation and the GNU project, is urging some free software groups not to promote Ubuntu because it sells user data to Amazon. Is he right? Has Ubuntu essentially become a spyware OS?

Answer this Question

Answers

2 total
ttopp
Vote Up (12)

Well, yes, he does have a point, at least somewhat. I'm not down with my information being given to a third party willy-nilly, but to some degree that happens nearly every minute we are online. I understand the need for Canonical to monetize Ubuntu, but I'm not sure this Amazon deal was the way to go. Nevertheless, it should be pointed out that this data sharing is only integrated into the desktop search function (as far as I know), and users can opt out. If Canonical had gone the other way, and made it opt-in, I wouldn't see it as much of a problem, but realistically how many people are going to take steps to opt-in. If I had to speculate, I would put that number down in the zero range.    

jimlynch
Vote Up (11)

He's right to point out what Ubuntu is doing, but he's a bit of a drama queen to call the entire Ubuntu OS "spyware." Users can opt out, so it's not being forced on them. Most Linux users are pretty savvy, and know how to deal with such things.

Ask a question

Join Now or Sign In to ask a question.
Red Hat has successfully grown Linux into an enterprise platform, now it's looking to do the same with OpenStack
Whether it's the first time you've picked up an iPad or the seventeenth time you've pulled out your iPhone today, there are probably still some iOS 7 features and functionality that you're not familiar with. Don't sweat it: We're here to help. We've collected some of our favorite and most useful tips and compiled them here, just for you.
Microsoft may have retired Windows XP, but one of China's leading security vendors is trying to keep the OS threat-free, and rolling out protection software to hundreds of millions of users in the nation.
Reduce your exposure to spying eyes with sandboxing, disk encryption and more.
Just days before Microsoft retired Windows XP from public support, the company drastically reduced the price of custom support agreements that give large companies and government agencies another year of XP patches, experts reported today.
Red Hat is looking to advance the Docker Linux container application for wider enterprise use.
As organizations move in-house systems to the cloud, Canonical wants them to consider switching their OSes as well.
Universal Windows apps will bring with it universal pricing--which, at least for the Windows Store, will mean the option of lower prices for all. And it's live now.
Microsoft on Monday conceded that Google's Chrome OS and the Chromebooks the operating system powers are capable of doing real work, a reversal of its 'Scroogled' campaign that once blasted the laptops as worthless.
Microsoft pays some companies to produce Windows 8 versions of their products. Without this type of financial assistance, or various other incentives, is Windows 8 and especially Windows Phone development worth the effort?