Is Richard Stallman right when he calls Ubuntu "spyware"?

jluppino

Apparently Richard Stallman, founder of the Free Software Foundation and the GNU project, is urging some free software groups not to promote Ubuntu because it sells user data to Amazon. Is he right? Has Ubuntu essentially become a spyware OS?

Answer this Question

Answers

2 total
jimlynch
Vote Up (17)

He's right to point out what Ubuntu is doing, but he's a bit of a drama queen to call the entire Ubuntu OS "spyware." Users can opt out, so it's not being forced on them. Most Linux users are pretty savvy, and know how to deal with such things.

ttopp
Vote Up (17)

Well, yes, he does have a point, at least somewhat. I'm not down with my information being given to a third party willy-nilly, but to some degree that happens nearly every minute we are online. I understand the need for Canonical to monetize Ubuntu, but I'm not sure this Amazon deal was the way to go. Nevertheless, it should be pointed out that this data sharing is only integrated into the desktop search function (as far as I know), and users can opt out. If Canonical had gone the other way, and made it opt-in, I wouldn't see it as much of a problem, but realistically how many people are going to take steps to opt-in. If I had to speculate, I would put that number down in the zero range.    

Ask a question

Join Now or Sign In to ask a question.
A couple more Windows Phone features are apparently headed to Windows 9, with signs of Wi-Fi Sense and Storage Sense showing up in the latest leaked preview builds.
The new Windows is coming, and it looks a lot more like Windows.
Linux Mint 17 offers long-term support; emerges as open source alternative for Windows XP users.
A free Windows 9 'Threshold' would allow Microsoft to push more than half of all Windows 8 users to the upgrade within months, share data shows.
Apple's not-yet-shipped OS X Yosemite has gotten a jump on grabbing users, thanks to the company's free beta program, data released Monday showed.
iOS 8 has several features that business users will love and use. Here are the ones to look forward to the most.
You don't need an electrical engineering degree to build a robot army. With the $35 Raspberry Pi B+, you can create robots and connected devices on the cheap, with little more than an Internet connection and a bunch of spare time.
A prominent Linux kernel developer has been jailed by Russian authorities after protesting publicly in Moscow's Manezh Square against the conflict in Ukraine.
BlackBerry, Tizen, Ubuntu Touch and Firefox OS take different approaches to staying alive.
Join us:
Facebook

Twitter

Pinterest

Tumblr

LinkedIn

Google+

randomness