Did Microsoft make to right call in reversing used game policies for the XBox One?


It looks like all the negative blog posts, articles and jokes on late night TV convinced MS to alter plans for the XBox One so that it won’t include the used game restrictions that had many people up in arms. I also wonder if much of the problem for MS was that many people are simply resistant to change, and perhaps once the new system had been in place, it would have not been accepted. After all, quite a few game developers have gone under in the past few years, and perhaps they would have benefited from the now defunct policy.

Answer this Question


2 total
Vote Up (9)

They kind of had to, or Sony was going to take them to the cleaners with the PS4. The company certainly didn’t communicate effectively how in most of the decisions that were being panned could in any way be positive for consumers. Also, even though developers and publishers dislike used games, I have yet to see compelling evidence that it significantly affects game sales. The removal of the requirement that the XBox One be connected online in order to function is probably positive. I can see making it where the owner has a strong incentive to have a persistent connection, but the reality is that in many parts of the US (and world) there is still a lack of high speed access, so making it mandatory would make the much XBox One less attractive to those potential customers. On the downside, it slows integration of the cloud with gaming, but I don’t think most gamers care about that.   

Vote Up (7)

If the hue and cry is loud enough, most companies will listen, including Microsoft. It sounds like they did the right thing, but not without prompting from users.

Ask a question

Join Now or Sign In to ask a question.
Also a few notes from Sony's pre-Tokyo Game Show press conference.
Here's how to keep tabs on happenings at DragonCon and PAX remotely. Also the XBox One September update arrives early, and brings with it some handy SmartGlass improvements
Twitter is useful for more than following your favorite celebrities. It's a powerful professional tool for keeping up on industry news, interacting with influencers, and marketing yourself. But when you use it this way, managing your Twitter account can feel like a full-time job--unless you have the right app, of course. Here are five iOS apps that make it a lot less work.
Samsung and LG have announced more smartwatches ahead of next week's IFA trade show in Berlin, with an emphasis on connectivity and curvy faces.
The Association for Unmanned Vehicle Systems International (AUVSI), which represents the nascent commercial drone industry in the U.S., has thrown its considerable weight behind a bid by Amazon to test drones for use in the online retailer's proposed Prime Air package delivery service.
Is it crazy to pay $1300 for a Chromebook? Some reflections after a year and a half of living with Google's luxurious Pixel.
Although forecasts for PC shipments have brightened, much of the improvement stems from bets that Chromebooks and Macs will make up a larger part of this year's market.
Big smartphones with screens larger than 5.5-in. will make up nearly a third of the entire smartphone market in 2018, IDC said.
We've heard rumor after rumor, but now it's official: Apple will be holding a press event on September 9, kicking off at 10 a.m. Pacific/1 p.m. Eastern. Invitations dispatched to press on Thursday morning were even more cryptic than usual, with a white-on-white Apple logo, the date, and a message reading "Wish we could say more."
Leap Motion may have a new lease on life thanks to inexpensive virtual reality headsets like the Oculus Rift.
Join us: