How do you feel about Facebook performing psychology experiments on users without consent?


Facebook was helping psychology researchers determine whether being exposed to disproportionately positive or negative posts in peoples’ newsfeed caused them to in turn be more negative or positive. Turns out, yes, seeing more negative posts tended to cause people to in turn be more negative with their later posts, and in turn seeing more positive posts caused them to be more positive. Ok, not surprising (ever read the comments on Fox News?) but mildly interesting. However, I’m not happy being made to dance like a puppet without being told. What do you think - was Facebook being a good guy by helping researchers, or a jerk for manipulating users without telling them?

Answer this Question


2 total
Vote Up (3)

its been awhile since I was in college, but one of the eethical constraints when studying human subjects was that they give informed consent. Obviously, the people being used in this research did not,  and it is hard not to feel resentment when a company manipulates you emotional reactions just to see how you will react. That said, I'm not really surprised that Facebook did it, I'm just surprised that the researchers thought it was ethical.


Let's face it,  companies including Facebook manipulate users constantly. They are constantly making changes and gauging the reactions. Then they make more changes and repeat the process. So when I think about this logically,  my reaction is that for once they were trying to do something in the pursuit of knowledge instead of profits. However, my emotional reaction is less charitable.  

Vote Up (2)

I loathe Facebook. I detest it. I closed my account a while back and I'm glad I did. This latest revelation of experiments just reconfirms my decision to get away from Facebook altogether, it's flat out evil of them to do something like this.

Here's my take on why I closed my Facebook account, and remember it was written long before this experiment was done or I would have included that as a reason too!

Ask a question

Join Now or Sign In to ask a question.
Here's how to keep tabs on happenings at DragonCon and PAX remotely. Also the XBox One September update arrives early, and brings with it some handy SmartGlass improvements
Twitter is useful for more than following your favorite celebrities. It's a powerful professional tool for keeping up on industry news, interacting with influencers, and marketing yourself. But when you use it this way, managing your Twitter account can feel like a full-time job--unless you have the right app, of course. Here are five iOS apps that make it a lot less work.
Samsung and LG have announced more smartwatches ahead of next week's IFA trade show in Berlin, with an emphasis on connectivity and curvy faces.
The Association for Unmanned Vehicle Systems International (AUVSI), which represents the nascent commercial drone industry in the U.S., has thrown its considerable weight behind a bid by Amazon to test drones for use in the online retailer's proposed Prime Air package delivery service.
Is it crazy to pay $1300 for a Chromebook? Some reflections after a year and a half of living with Google's luxurious Pixel.
Although forecasts for PC shipments have brightened, much of the improvement stems from bets that Chromebooks and Macs will make up a larger part of this year's market.
Big smartphones with screens larger than 5.5-in. will make up nearly a third of the entire smartphone market in 2018, IDC said.
We've heard rumor after rumor, but now it's official: Apple will be holding a press event on September 9, kicking off at 10 a.m. Pacific/1 p.m. Eastern. Invitations dispatched to press on Thursday morning were even more cryptic than usual, with a white-on-white Apple logo, the date, and a message reading "Wish we could say more."
Leap Motion may have a new lease on life thanks to inexpensive virtual reality headsets like the Oculus Rift.
In June, Rhapsody and T-Mobile announced Rhapsody unRadio, a subscription streaming music service. This isn't the first time we've seen such an arrangement. Mobile carriers and music streaming services are increasingly getting together in this one-hand-washes-the-other kind of way (as evidenced by the relationships between AT&T and Beats Music and Sprint and Spotify). Getting free or less-expensive music streaming is a perk that might attract customers to a particular carrier, and pre-packaging the services with specific data plans increases the services' visibility.
Join us: