Is photorealism in gaming really desirable?


Tim Sweeney, the guy who developed the Unreal Engine and founder of Epic Games, recently said that he is certain that in 10 years, video games will be photorealistic and the graphics will be indistinguishable from reality. I’m not sure this is completely a positive thing. Development costs are already huge for major titles, and I would think that the greater the level of detail, the greater the development cost. Plus, the gaming words are an escape from reality; I’m not sure that it will be as escapist if everything just looks real. What do you think - is photorealism a goal worth achieving?

Answer this Question


2 total
Vote Up (13)

Some games will probably use it, and some won't. There will always be a variety of gaming art and style, so I wouldn't worry too much about it. Game makers will go where the money is too, and I doubt everybody would want that kind of game.

Vote Up (12)

Graphics may not make the game, but they can aid in the immersive experience. You point out that maybe looking too real would destroy the suspension of disbelief (I paraphrase, obviously). Don’t forget, this could also mean a photorealistic fantastic world, where everything that is normal is turned upside down. It could be a little disturbing if some things look absolutely real. I might stop doing things like getting my money back from, ahem, “ladies of the evening” in GTA for example. But think how awesome racing games and sports games would be with photorealistic graphics. Very, I think.


Where I do agree with you is development costs, and the results of that. What you see already in game development is that companies tend to play it safe with their $100 million dollar development titles. 

Ask a question

Join Now or Sign In to ask a question.
In the U.S. alone, nearly $2 billion worth of Apple devices -- Macs, iPhones, iPads and iPods -- were sold on eBay over the last 12 months.
From now until the end of the month you can get a free copy of The Sims 2 through Origin.
As iOS 8--and, presumably, new iPhone and iPad hardware--approaches its release day, big changes are on the horizon for Apple's Touch ID, a technology that has been met with less enthusiasm than it deserves.
In happier news, next week your PS4 will be able to play 3D Blu-rays, and why that matters.
After seventeen years, Valve and ValveTime Database give us our first look at screenshots from the unreleased 1996 title Prospero.
Who needs a Fitbit anyway? Your iPhone can track your steps for you, but not every pedometer app can go the distance.
Nividia ought to market this new device as a solid general purpose tablet that also happens to play games.
Wireless broadband subscriptions now outnumber people in seven countries as consumers continue to snap up smartphones and tablets, according to a new report.
You might not be familiar with the term "cramming." But if you're not careful, it could be costing you money on your mobile phone bill each month.
Those Normal 3D printed earbuds we looked at a few weeks ago have some competition, and OwnPhones are wireless (and of course, more expensive).
Join us: