Would you buy an "always online" game console?

jackson

Rumors suggest the next gen XBox will require that it be online at all times to play games. I'm still deciding which of the next gen consoles to get, but where I live it is not uncommon for my internet connection to drop for a few seconds (thanks AT&T). If this causes games to pause (or worse) during single-player gaming, I could easily see the cost of the console purchase being exceeded by the need to purchase new controllers and windows that said controllers gets thrown through. Maybe not really, but I could see this being extremely frustrating. I don't think I would be very good taking (former) Microsoft Studios creative director Adam Orth's advice to "#dealwithit".  Am I an outlier here, the one gamer with an internet connection that isn't perfectly reliable, or would Microsoft and other console manufacturers be shooting themselves in the foot by building "always online" hardware?

Answer this Question

Answers

3 total
jimlynch
Vote Up (1)

No, why would anybody want to have such a system? There may be times when it can't connect, so why should it not work? Besides, sometimes you need to disconnect and playing videogames should facilitate that for the people who prefer it.

So I wouldn't buy it.

dniblock
Vote Up (2)

I suppose I would, but I don't look at it as a positive. It adds too many failure points for my liking. I don't see the need for it, plus when everyone at my house is doing their own thing on my home network, it has a big impact (3-4 people streaming Netfix, watching YouTube, on Skype, etc. can use some bandwidth). It wouldn't be the sole determinant in my decision, but if the new XBox and PS4 are otherwise similar and only one of them requires a persistent internet connection even when playing single player games, that would certainly be a factor I would consider. I usually end up getting at least 2 of the 3 consoles in each generation anyway, but it would make me more likely to wait to see what impact it has on other users' experiences.

kreiley
Vote Up (0)

Just an FYI, recent news indicates that the next XBox will function when it is not online, at least according to this article, which makes sense unless Microsoft really wants to annoy a large number of potential customers. 

Ask a question

Join Now or Sign In to ask a question.
Ouya gets $15 million in funding, delays launch and improves their controller. Meanwhile Gamepop offers a subscription-based Android gaming solution for your TV. But many questions remain.
The Donald wants FundAnything to be like Kickstarter, only gaudier
A new competitor, BlueStacks, wants to bring subscription-based Android gaming to your TV with yet another cheaply priced console.
If you weren't one of the early backers of Ouya's $100 Android game console, you'll have to wait a little bit longer to get one.
And I finally get around to mentioning the Time Warner Cable Roku Channel, too.
Yesterday we got word of another confirmed next gen title launching in Q4 of this year. Plus good and bad news for Wii U owners, and Sony gets even more indie-friendly.
Small, not obscenely expensive, and capable of accessing media locally as well as online, the Mac mini has a lot going for it. But is it the perfect solution for those anxious to cut the media cord? I spent a month with one to find out.
If you've been waiting for a discount, it's time to buy: Barnes & Noble is slashing Nook tablet prices by up to 30 percent as part of a limited Mother's Day promotion.
A trifecta of gaming news shorts today, with the most important being about the much-rumored "always connected" aspect of the next Xbox. Never fear, you'll be able to play single player games without being online.
Two prominent gaming veterans have joined "Android Play Studio" just ahead of a gaming-filled schedule at Google I/O 2013.