Would you still use a movie service if it used camera to monitor the number of people watching?


This one kind of blew my mind, but Microsoft filed a patent for technology to use a camera (like, oh, the Kinect for instance) to keep track of the number of people that are watching a movie, and presumably charge an additional fee if there are too many people watching it. Seriously. http://www.kotaku.com.au/2012/11/this-kinect-patent-is-terrifying-wants-...

Would they actually try to do this? Would anyone in their right mind agree to terms of service that allowed it? When I was a little kid, I used to refuse to put on my PJs if the TV was on because I was afraid someone might be watching. Now I'm thinking perhaps I was just ahead of my time, and need to re-establish some of my childhood neurotic behavior.

Answer this Question


3 total
Vote Up (10)

No, I wouldn't use it. Initially, people might not know about it. But word would get out and a lot of people would opt not to use it. So I think it would be a loser financially at some point. A very dumb idea.

Christopher Nerney
Vote Up (8)

No, I wouldn't, and I can't believe anyone else would knowingly do it. Talk about an invasion of privacy! 


People agree to all kinds of things in terms of service that they never bother to read, so plenty of people might inadvertently sign off on it. But I don't see this getting past the patent stage. It's such an offensive idea that I have to believe such a set-up would be doomed to fail.



Vote Up (7)

All sorts of stupid things get patented, without being actually produced.  I think that this is probably one of those, although you never know.  I can't imagine anything but a storm of negative publicity if this was ever implemented, assuming that the average Joe ever learned about it.  The only upside I can see from this patent is that it makes it slighly harder for some other evil entity to put the technology into use.    

Ask a question

Join Now or Sign In to ask a question.
Also Spiderman may be avoiding the Xbox One, and Playstation Now is coming to Bravia TVs
Five music labels have filed a lawsuit against streaming music service Pandora Music, saying the company is violating state law by refusing to pay labels and artists for its use of recordings made before 1972.
Streaming your games for others to watch on Twitch is a big fad these days, but it looks like the company is taking the first tentative steps towards branching into other areas.
Sales of Sony's PlayStation 4 platform have surpassed 7 million units worldwide but supply problems are continuing, the electronics giant said.
IHS says Samsung's new phone costs $251 for materials, $51 more than the retail cost of a carrier-subsidized unit.
Did you think the 3D craze had run its course? Me too. Apparently Amazon didn't get the memo.
According to a new dataset, the big names in technology lag well behind actors, politicians and athletes in terms of global cultural significance
More low-end Android gaming consoles are coming to China. But Microsoft's local partner isn't worried, and expects the Xbox to sell well as a high-end gaming product.
Spend some time with a BlackBerry 10 device and you just might put your iPhone away for good. Here are the nine steps it takes to move from an iPhone 5S to a BlackBerry Z30.
Free Wi-Fi aggregator Fon is hoping to boost the popularity of its network with the Gramofon, a router that integrates music streaming. The first service to be added is Spotify, but more are on the way.

White Papers & Webcasts

See more White Papers | Webcasts

Join us: