Are criminal penalties for hacking excessive?


This week Andrew Auernheimer was sentence to 41 months (!) in prison for exposing an AT&T security flaw. I know that is a bit biased in how I stated it, but he found and exploited a weakness that AT&T should be hanging their head over, didn't use any of the information he was able to access to take anything, and turned it over the Gawker to publicize the issue. Aurenheimer may come off as a bit of a jerk at times, but 41 months in federal prison for THAT?!? It was only a month or so ago that Aaron Swartz committed suicide while facing 35 years in federal prison + a $1,000,000 fine for accessing a server and downloading a ton of academic articles. I know it sounds cliché, but people really do often get lesser sentences for killing people. 


On the other hand, I've had a personal account compromised in the past, and I would love for whoever did it to spend some time in prison (but even then not decades). What do people think; Are the punishments for hacking under the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act unfair, or is it what we need to dissuade people from committing cybercrimes? 

Topic: Security
Answer this Question


3 total
Vote Up (11)

Perhaps AT&T should have hired him as a security consultant? He did seem to provide an important service to them. So rather than prosecuting him, maybe they should have hired him to take advantage of his skill sets?

Vote Up (11)

I think it is out of balance, and I entirely agree with Christopher's contrasting example of bankers and execs getting off with ZERO personal liability when their actions ruin people's lives. I personally lost well over $100,000 when the financial system nearly collapsed, and I don't know when I'll ever catch back up. Yet the people who caused it walk free and get million dollar bonuses.

The problem is that many prosecutors just don't care about the relative moral implications of actions they prosecute. They see a law, they can prosecute people for it, and they seek the maximum penalty nearly every time. If you don't want to face the possibility of decades in jail, which is a very real possibility even if you are actually innocent, you have to accept their plea offer. Take it or leave it.

Back to the original question, yes, I do think the penalties are out of control for some things. To me, it is somewhat like John Stewart Mill's Harm Principle, and if the individual is not causing direct harm to others, they should be punished very little or not at all. The Auernheimer case would fall into this category, and it is reasonably arguable that his actions actually benefited millions of iPad users. If the miscreants are causing direct harm to others, such as Christopher's examples of stolen credit cards and on-line harassment, then I am all for Old Testament style, merciless punishment.  Prosecutors have demonstrated that they are unwilling to appreciate the difference, so the only answer is to change the laws.

Christopher Nerney
Vote Up (10)

It depends. In the cases you cite, the sentences definitely appear to be excessive.


However, in this case and this case, it can fairly be argued that the longer sentences may be more appropriate. For me, stealing money and credit cards or harassing, stalking and terrorizing people online are deserving of harsh punishment. Hacking into a network for fun or to prove a point, not so much. 


All that being said, there's something wrong when hackers get excessive sentences for committing lesser crimes than the bankers and other corporate executives who routinely abuse our laws and economic system and ruin lives for their own personal financial gain. 


Ask a question

Join Now or Sign In to ask a question.
A hacker group calling itself "Anonymous Kenya" has poked holes at the government's cybersecurity preparedness by hacking two official Twitter accounts.
New guidance from Microsoft researchers suggests that users re-use simple passwords and avoid password management services.
Apple has "inadvertently admitted" to creating a "backdoor" in iOS, according to a post by a forensics scientist, iOS author and ex-hacker.
A critical vulnerability found recently in a popular newsletter plug-in for WordPress is actively being targeted by hackers and was used to compromise an estimated 50,000 sites so far.
Google, Microsoft and Yahoo are meeting with European data protection authorities Thursday to discuss how to implement a recent ruling that gives people the right to have personal information excluded from search results.
Hackers have stolen user contact information, including email addresses and phone numbers, from the website of the European Central Bank and attempted to extort money from the institution.
EBay faces a class action suit in a U.S. federal court over a security breach earlier this year.
A vulnerability broker published a video demonstrating one of several flaws it has found in the privacy-focused Tails operating system, which is used by those seeking to make their Web browser harder to trace.
Juniper Networks has divested its mobile security product line, selling the assets to a private equity firm for $250 million.
Six people have been indicted on charges of running an international ring that resold tickets bought through compromised StubHub accounts for some of New York's biggest concerts and sporting events.
Join us: