How do you feel about Microsoft's remote kill switch for Windows 8? Is it a legitimate security measure or overreach?

wstark

Apparently MS is enabling a "kill switch" to enable them to remotely remove apps from your machine, with the added effect that any data generated by the app may disappear as well. I understand the idea that Microsoft could provide an important service by removing malware, but I'm not sure I am comfortable with Microsoft being able to delete my data remotely whenever they wish, even if it is related to a security concern. I can help but think that it will be just as likely that apps get zapped for reasons other than security. Is this the future of security or is Microsoft going a step too far with this?

Topic: Security
Answer this Question

Answers

2 total
jimlynch
Vote Up (4)

The real issue here is that a lot of people simply don't trust Microsoft. Is it fair or justified? Well, given the company's past behavior I'd say yes. Microsoft has nobody to blame but themselves for this, distrust and suspicion are rooted in the history of that company.

If it really bothers you though, perhaps it's time to consider a switch to Linux? Go to http://distrowatch.com and you can find lots of distros to choose from if you want to make the switch. Linux has a lot to offer and Windows 8 might be the straw that broke the camel's back for a lot of people.

hughye
Vote Up (7)

Google has a kill switch, and has used it in the past a few times without much if any complaint.  Apple has one in iOS, but to the best of my knowledge it has never been utilized.  The underlying idea of being able to kill apps that are malware in disguise is a valid and potentially valuable capability.  Think about how many people there are out there that do not take even the most basic precautions against viruses/malware.  Some people don't run any anti-virus/malware software at all, and there is also a significant number of people who never even update their OS, thus leaving them unnecessarily vulnerable.  So in that it could protect people against their own sloth, I think a remote kill switch could be a good thing.

 

However, there is no certainty that Microsoft is going to use it in a purely protective manner.  What happens if there is a dispute between Microsoft and an application developer, unrelated to security, and Microsoft decides to use their power to simply remove the application, along with associated data, from every machine in the World that is running Windows 8?  I do not like the thought of that at all.       

 

So in the end, I am rather conflicted about the clear benefits that could be provided by Microsoft having a remote kill switch for malware versus the requirement that I surrender control over my own machine to Microsoft and trust in the good will and judgment of the company.  That latter concern leaves me quite vexed, to be honest.  

Ask a question

Join Now or Sign In to ask a question.
The mayor of West New York, New Jersey, was arrested together with his son on Thursday, for allegedly hacking into a website that criticized him and his administration.
Absinthe 2.0, the jailbreak for iOS 5.1.1, is ready and available for download, the Jailbreak Dream Team announced at the Hack in the Box conference in Amsterdam on Friday.
A federal judge in Kentucky this week upheld a lower court's decision to throw out crucial evidence in a drug case because the evidence was gathered with the help of a GPS tracking device installed without a warrant.
Two U.S. lawmakers have called on the U.S. Department of Justice to reopen its investigation into Google's snooping on Wi-Fi networks in 2010 after recent questions about the company's level of cooperation with federal inquiries.
A pair of security researchers have proposed an extension to the Transport Layer Security (TLS) protocol that would allow browsers to detect and block fraudulently-issued SSL certificates.
The touch-centric Metro version of Internet Explorer 10 in Windows 8 is plug-in free, but the browser may still be able to run Adobe Flash video, according to an online report. Microsoft is reportedly taking the Google Chrome approach with IE10 and building Flash capability directly into the touch-friendly browser. But Flash won't be available for every site on the Web in Metro IE10. Instead, Microsoft will only extend the capability to select popular sites, according to Windows bloggers Paul Thurrott and Rafael Rivera.
Yahoo was forced to release a new version of its Axis extension for Google Chrome after the original one contained a private key that allowed anyone to digitally sign extensions in Yahoo's name.
More than 95 percent of over 600 SAP systems tested by security firm Onapsis were vulnerable to espionage, sabotage and fraud, mainly because patches had not been applied, according to a researcher.
Security researchers unveiled eight vulnerabilities in Google services during the Hack in the Box conference in Amsterdam on Thursday -- but they claim to have discovered more than 100 such bugs over the past few months.

White Papers & Webcasts

White Paper

IDC Vendor Spotlight

Your company needs backup and recovery that supports a tiered-recovery model. This IDC Vendor Spotlight examines the modern forces driving the advancements in today's data protection technologies, and a complete backup and recovery solution that works across physical, virtual and cloud environments.

White Paper

vRanger Helps Cut Replication Time by Almost 70%

There's a reason why more than 38,000 customers trust vRanger to protect their critical virtual data! In this Quest Software case study, see how vRanger helped Cornerstone Bancshares, Inc. cut replication time from days to minutes - and how this translated to real time and money savings.

White Paper

ESG: Product Brief: Quest vRanger 5.3 brings enterprise-class VMware protection to SMB's

Free paper: how virtualization impacts SMBs, and strategies for enterprise-class VMware protection

White Paper

Forrester Report: The ROI of Cloud Apps

Cloud apps continue to gain momentum in the enterprise as buyers are attracted to fast deployment speeds, low upfront costs, and ongoing flexibility to scale up or down as needs change. This report analyzes the five-year ROI for cloud apps across CRM, ERP, collaboration, and IT service management.

White Paper

The Cloud: Reinventing Enterprise Collaboration

Collaboration and content sharing are not, of course, new concepts. But cloud computing has changed the nature of collaboration, content sharing, document storage and project management to enable more efficient, faster-acting and cost-effective enterprises. According to a new study by IDG Research, the vast majority of knowledge workers (86%) placed a very high level of importance on collaborating with internal coworkers and external stakeholders, and having access to the most up-to-date corporate information. Read how organizations are realizing massive productivity gains by transitioning their content management solutions to cloud-based models.

See more White Papers | Webcasts