How much validity to claims that antivirus software is “dead?”


Symantec's Senior VP Brian Dye said during an interview with The Wall Street Journal that antivirus software “is dead” and the company no longer considers it a money maker. Of much more concern to me than Symantecs balance sheet, Dye also said that their antivirus software only catches about 40% of all cyber-attacks. Does he have a point? Is the antivirus software most of us run more valuable for a placebo effect to make us feel better than it is for actual protection?

Topic: Security
Answer this Question


3 total
Vote Up (4)

Yes, but what does he mean by “cyberattacks?” Spear-phishing? Classic hacking? DoS? In any case, I agree with KerryBlake that there is still a role for antivirus software in a multilayer system. After all, even if it only stops 40% of “cyberattacks” (although I suspect the number is much higher for malware), that is still 4 out of 10 attacks that don’t do damage. Combined with other layers of defense (cloud providers, server based, firewalls, etc.), AV software gives you another piece of the puzzle to work with, even if it is not a perfect solution.

Vote Up (4)

Hey Travis,


if you take that most people use Internet and Cloud computing these days which automaticly make your computer "safe" from conventional viruses that shared mostly from CD's or USB's you could agree with Dye. So, maybe you could say that antivirus software for personal use is "dead", on the other hand, web sites and cloud service providers should and will scan everything that goes on their servers. So, in that department I would say that antivirus software will go on living.


Hope this helps.

Vote Up (2)

I don't know, I've been running Linux and OS X for so long that I haven't used antivirus in years and years. Maybe an OS switch would be a good idea if viruses are a concern for you.

Ask a question

Join Now or Sign In to ask a question.
Attackers are exploiting a vulnerability in distributed search engine software Elasticsearch to install DDoS malware on Amazon and possibly other cloud servers.
Vulnerabilities in the Tails operating system could reveal your IP address, but you can avoid trouble by taking a couple of precautions.
Financial institutions use many technologies to fight crime, but much of the work comes too late, focusing on suspicious activity, like uncharacteristic charges or money transfers, after it happens.
Dennis Technology Labs says it tested it because of marketing claims for it; Malwarebytes says free version of product is just a clean-up tool.
A new survey of IT security professionals shows that many businesses are barely starting to exploit mobile technology, and some of them may be a mobile security nightmare waiting to happen.
The Russian Ministry of Interior is willing to pay 3.9 million roubles, or around US$111,000, for a method to identify users on the Tor network.
Public certificate authorities (CAs) are warning that as of Nov. 1 they will reject requests for internal SSL server certificates that don't conform to new internal domain naming and IP address conventions designed to safeguard networks.
European data protection authorities still have questions after meeting with Google, Microsoft and Yahoo about the implementation of a recent ruling that gave European citizens the right to be forgotten by search engines.
An iPhone user has filed a lawsuit for invasion of privacy against Apple, about a week after a Chinese state broadcaster raised security concerns about the device's location-tracking functions.
Handling a software flaw can be messy, both for a security researcher who found it and for the company it affects. But a new set of guidelines aims to make that interaction less mysterious and confrontational.
Join us: