More legal setbacks for Apple

Company on losing end of court rulings Friday in Australia and Germany


It's been a tough week for Apple on the patent-war front.

First a judge in China on Tuesday rejected the company's lawsuits against a Chinese firm that says it holds the trademark to "iPad" in that country. Score one against Cupertino.

Then, on Friday, Apple lost two more battles in international courts. In Australia, a three-judge panel ruled that Samsung Electronics could begin selling its Galaxy 10.1 tablets before Christmas, ending a ban on sales prompted by Apple's lawsuit arguing that Samsung's device infringed on the company's touch-screen patents. The decision overturned a ruling last week that reinstated the ban. Score another against Cupertino.

Also on Friday, a German court issued an injunction prohibiting the sale of iPhones and iPads, arguing that the products infringe on a Motorola patent. There's three courtroom setbacks for Apple.

None of these decisions mark the end of the legal battles Apple is fighting with Samsung and Motorola -- if you have enough lawyers and money, litigation seemingly can go on forever. But they're certainly short-term blows to the company.

Apple did, however, gain a court victory in France this week. The company on Thursday said a French court rejected a preliminary injunction sought by Samsung to halt sales of the iPhone 4S.

This week's flurry of legal decisions comes after a U.S. court last week denied Apple's request that sales of four Samsung products -- the Galaxy 10.1, Galaxy S 4G, Infuse 4G and Droid Charge -- be halted.

If Steve Jobs were alive, it's safe to say he'd be going thermonuclear over this recent spate of courtroom losses, perhaps railing against the "bozo explosion" afflicting the judiciary.

Now Read This: IT Resume Makeover: Our top 11 tips
View Comments
You Might Like
Join the discussion
Be the first to comment on this article. Our Commenting Policies