Standard & Poor's gives Google the U.S. debt treatment

S&P equity analysts downgrade search giant in wake of Motorola Mobility purchase

First, the U.S. debt rating. And now Google. Standard & Poor's on Tuesday downgraded Google's stock (NASDAQ: GOOG) to a "sell" from a "buy" in the wake of the search giant's $12.5 billion acquisition Monday of Motorola Mobility. S&P lowered Google's price target to $500 from $700.

[Are Motorola's patents enough to protect Android? and Motorola workers likely thrilled by Google's buy]

Shares of Google fell 18.23, or 3.3%, to 539 in Tuesday's trading. Since July 26, Google shares are down 14.1%. For the year, Google's stock is down 9.3%. In announcing the downgrade, S&P analyst Scott Kessler said the acquisition of Motorola Mobility -- maker of smartphones running on Google's Android mobile OS and possessor of about 17,000 mobile and wireless patents -- poses "greater risk to the company and stock." From USA Today:

Kessler noted that despite Motorola Mobility's "extensive and and valuable patent portfolio," S&P wasn't sure it could protect Android from intellectual property disputes.

Further, he noted, the Goolge-Motorola deal would negatively hit the search giant's growth and financials.

That's because in buying Motorola Mobility, Google acquired a low-margin device manufacturer with a huge payroll. In contrast, Google's core business -- online advertising revenue derived from its market-leading search engine -- generates tremendous margins. (Business Insider's Henry Blodget published a long column Tuesday detailing why he thinks "Google-Motorola will be a colossal disaster. It's an interesting read.) S&P, of course, triggered a fusillade of political finger-pointing on Aug. 5 when it downgraded U.S. debt to AA from AAA, citing ongoing dysfunctionality in Washington regarding the debt ceiling, deficit spending and general economic idiocy.

What’s wrong? The new clean desk test
Join the discussion
Be the first to comment on this article. Our Commenting Policies