This is no NetMeeting

RELATED TOPICS

Many of you responded to the newsletter about Windows XP a couple of weeks ago, with the bulk of the messages reminding me that Microsoft's NetMeeting includes remote-control software.

I was already aware of NetMeeting's remote-control facilities. I was even aware that it shipped with Windows 2000 (unlike earlier operating systems). Perhaps I should have mentioned that in the newsletter, to both forestall the mail avalanche as well as to point out why XP's remote control is so much more of a problem.

NetMeeting is an application. Users (or administrators) can choose to install it or not. Users can choose to run it or not. Setting up remote control takes a number of actions on the user's part to enable the PC as a host. None of that is necessarily true for XP.

In XP, the remote-control function is an integral part of the operating system, giving you no choice about installation.

In XP, the remote-control function is an integral part of the operating system, and no choice about running an application is possible.

In XP, the remote-control function is an integral part of the operating system - just think of the security problems associated with other "integral" parts of the operating system (Internet Explorer, Windows scripting and so on).

Remote control delivered via an application isn't news - CloseUp, pcAnywhere and Carbon Copy were hot sellers for DOS machines a dozen years ago. NetMeeting simply took this and added Windows to the mix, and Microsoft wasn’t even first with that. Funk Software's Proxy (still going strong with a new Win 2000 version) was originally released for the Windows 3.x platform.

No, the real drawback to XP's remote-control system is precisely that it is no longer part of an application, but instead is buried inside the operating system and is subject to manipulation by the operating system-based API. That's what makes me worried.

This story, "This is no NetMeeting " was originally published by Network World.

RELATED TOPICS
Top 10 Hot Internet of Things Startups
View Comments
You Might Like
Join the discussion
Be the first to comment on this article. Our Commenting Policies