15 terrifying PC horror games to play with the lights off

Don't be ashamed to curl up in a ball in the corner. These PC horror games will scare the pants off of even hardened gamers.

besthorrorgames primary 100066190 large
The horror, the HORROR

Horror games are a dime a dozen. Good horror games—well, those are much rarer. We've rounded up some of the best horror games ever made, running the gamut from big-budget extravaganzas released this very year to... text adventures. I'm serious.

Turn out the lights, put on some headphones, make sure you've got a spare pair of underwear nearby, and enjoy these spine-tinglers.

alien isolation
Alien: Isolation

One alien. That was the design direction behind Creative Assembly's Alien: Isolation, which pursued the survival horror mood of the original 1979 film instead of the action-packed plot of Aliens.

And it worked. Though a bit overlong and at times needlessly difficult, Alien: Isolation is the strongest big-budget horror experience in years. This game is just plain tense—almost unbearably so if you play it with a VR headset.

Alien: Isolation

5 nights at freddys
Five Nights at Freddy's

You're the newest employee at Freddy Fazbear's Pizza, a Chuck-E-Cheese style chain where diners are entertained by a band of animatronic robots. All you have to do is hang out in the security booth all night—and survive when the robots spring to life with a thirst for your blood.

The fact that you can only watch the not-so-merry crew over grainy security cameras as they close in on your location gives the game an ominous, incredibly tense feel, though that fades after a few playthroughs.

Five Nights at Freddy's

amnesia dark descent
Amnesia: The Dark Descent

A Victorian-era castle may not seem like the best setting for a horror game, but with Amnesia: The Dark Descent Frictional took everything it learned from its earlier games, polished it, and released one of the scariest games of all time. You play as Daniel, an archeologist who's lost his memory and has only a letter—apparently written by him—to guide his escape from the mad castle and shadowy figures that stalk him.

While it's more polarizing, the sequel Machine for Pigs is also worth checking out, as long as you curb your expectations.

Amnesia: The Dark Descent

among the sleep
Among the Sleep

Nighttime is creepy. Nighttime as a baby is even creepier.

Among the Sleep is a first-person horror game where you're awakened in the middle of the night and must investigate. The twist? You're a two-year-old child. The game's a bit on the short side, but the atmosphere is fantastic, and there's no better way to feel vulnerable than to inhabit the body of a toddler.

Among the Sleep

outlast
Outlast

Asylums are easy fodder for horror. That said, Outlast makes the most of its clichéd setting by providing you no way to defend yourself and forcing you into the found-footage conceit popularized by horror films like Blair Witch Project. The game has some pacing issues, but it's definitely not for the faint of heart—gore and jump scares abound.

And if you already played and enjoyed the base Outlast game, be sure to check out the Whistleblower DLC released earlier this year.

Outlast

alan wake
Alan Wake

Alan Wake is one part Stephen King novel, one part Twin Peaks, and one part Twilight Zone episode—in other words, it's a horror fan's dream. Darkness is taking over the town of Bright Falls. Author Alan Wake realizes he's already written a book about the events, and it's slowly coming true, one page at a time.

Combat in Alan Wake is a bit clunky, but it's really Remedy's storytelling and atmosphere you're here for, both of which are superb.

Alan Wake

penumbra
Penumbra: Black Plague

Before there was Amnesia, there was Penumbra. Frictional's first horror series charged players with navigating an abandoned underground research compound. While the first game's cave system was a great start (Penumbra: Overture) it was Black Plague that will make you need a new pair of pants.

Penumbra: Black Plague

betrayer
Betrayer

Betrayer is rough around the edges, which is a shame, because at its best moments this atmospheric take on the vanished Roanoke colony is really, really creepy. Wandering the empty wilderness of Virginia, wind blowing balefully between the pines, hearing the far-off snorts of the animalistic Spaniards, flashes of red breaking the otherwise monochromatic environment... it’s enough to give you the shivers.

If only the game played better.

Betrayer

system shock 2
System Shock 2

Before BioShock there was System Shock.

It takes more than a few mods to get the best out of aging space horror game System Shock 2 nowadays, but it's worth it. System Shock 2 is legendary due both to the atmosphere of the starship Von Braun and the quality of its writing.

System Shock 2

dead space
Dead Space

If System Shock 2 is the best space-based survival horror game of all time—and it is—Dead Space is a close second. Engineer Isaac Clarke attempts to repair an enormous space station, only to find it's infested by aliens known as the Necromorphs.

Dead Space is essentially the horror game Doom 3 so desperately tried to be. It’s absolutely worth checking out.

Dead Space

anchorhead
Anchorhead

Scared by... a text adventure? It's true. The tale of a creepy old mansion and a young couple, Anchorhead is over fifteen years old at this point and owes a hefty amount to Mr. H.P. Lovecraft. Like a good horror novel, Anchorhead is less about jump-out-of-your-seat scares and more about creating tension, but it does that masterfully.

Plus it's free, like most modern text adventures, and playable through your browser.

Also worth checking out: Slouching Towards Bedlam, Vespers

condemned criminal origins
Condemned: Criminal Origins

There's a serial killer on the loose, and whoever it is really loves mannequins. You're a crime scene investigator and must catch this disturbing killer while also contending with your increasingly violent surroundings. Probably by hitting those surroundings (read: psychopaths) with a pipe.

Condemned is damn terrifying. You'll have nightmares about those mannequins.

Condemned: Criminal Origins

re4
Resident Evil 4

Resident Evil 4 is commonly cited as the best of the series, which is slightly funny if only because the game doesn't even revolve around the zombies the series is known for. Set in Spain, protagonist Leon Kennedy has to contend with a creepy cult pledged to "The Enlightened Ones."

The original PC port of Resident Evil 4 was trash, but earlier this year Capcom released Resident Evil 4: Ultimate HD, which seems to fix most of the issues while also improving the graphics.

Resident Evil 4

dreadhalls
Dreadhalls

Horror games on the Oculus Rift VR headset are about a thousand times more intense than they'd be if played on a normal monitor. Dreadhalls, a procedurally generated dungeon crawler, isn't the most polished nor the most graphically intensive game around, but it's a great proof-of-concept of horror in virtual reality.

Dreadhalls via Oculus Share

pathologic
Pathologic

Pathologic is like someone hired Kafka to write The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion. There's a plague killing The Town, and you play as one of three characters trying to unravel the mysteries held within. Many people will die.

You will probably fail at playing this game, and the translations are spotty at best. But it's cult-classic enough that Rock, Paper, Shotgun once wrote a three-part tome of an article about it, and Ice-Pick Lodge Kickstarted a more polished remake of the game earlier this year.

Pathologic

call of cthulu
Honorable mention: Call of Cthulu: Dark Corners of the Earth

I really, really want to include Call of Cthulu: Dark Corners of the Earth as it's one of my favorite horror games of all time. Unfortunately, this is a bit of a buyer-beware situation, as the version of the game on Steam is exceedingly buggy and crash-prone.

If you can find a more stable version, however, or can play on an old console, do so immediately. This is one of the finest examples of psychological horror ever done in video games, with the exception maybe of the Nintendo 64’s Eternal Darkness.