Cisco slaps Arista Networks with patent, copyright infringement suits

Cisco today filed two lawsuits against data center switch competitor Arista Networks for allegedly violating its intellectual property

120514 cisco arista

Cisco today filed two lawsuits against data center switch competitor Arista Networks for allegedly violating its intellectual property.

One suit is for patent infringement, which charges Arista with violating 14 Cisco patents for 12 features in the Arista EOS operating system. The second suit is for extensive copying of Cisco’s user manuals and command line structures, right down to the grammatical errors within them.

“This is not an accident but a strategy,” says a source familiar with the matter. “It was a deliberate, brazen and blatant intellectual property violation in order to gain competitive advantage in the marketplace. Arista’s shortcutting to get to market and win share.”

According to a blog posted by Cisco General Counsel Mark Chandler, Cisco has only sued a competitor less than a handful of times in the last 13 years.

+ALSO ON NETWORK WORLD: Celebrating 25 Years of Cisco Networkers +

Arista said it just became aware of the suits and had not yet had a chance to review the complaints in detail. But CEO Jayshree Ullal, a former Cisco executive, said, "I'm disappointed at Cisco's tactics. It's not the Cisco I knew."

Patent infringement

In Chandler’s blog post, Cisco identified 12 product features covered by 14 patents that Arista is said to have violated. “None of the implementations are incorporated in industry standards,” Chandler writes. “They were patented by individuals who worked for Cisco and are now at Arista, or who at Cisco worked with executives who are now at Arista. These Cisco-created features and implementations are incorporated by Arista in their entirety into Arista’s products.”

Arista, which went public in June, was founded by former Cisco employees, many of whom are named inventors on Cisco’s networking patents, the suit states. Among others, Arista’s founders, President and CEO, Chief Development Officer, Chief Technology Officer, Senior Vice President for Customer Engineering, Vice President of Systems Engineering and Technology Marketing, Vice President of Hardware Engineering, Vice President of Software Engineering, and Vice President of Manufacturing and Platform Engineering.

+ ALSO ON NETWORK WORLD Critical milestones in Cisco's history +

“Notably, Arista was founded by former Cisco employees who were intimately and directly familiar with Cisco’s patented networking technologies, including those protected by patents asserted in this action,” the suit states. “Two of Arista’s founders, Andreas Bechtolsheim and David Cheriton, developed patented

1 2 Page 1
ITWorld DealPost: The best in tech deals and discounts.
Shop Tech Products at Amazon