The government running Google? What could possibly go wrong?

Are Google’s products and services becoming a critical infrastructure that the government should ensure survives?


Should Sergey Brin be worried that Google may someday be subject to government control?

Image credit: REUTERS/Robert Galbraith

The (impending) demise of Google Reader has caused an immediate problem for those of us who still still use it regularly, forcing us to find a new RSS reader. But could Google’s decision to shut down Reader (and other services) ultimately lead to a bigger problem down the road for Google itself? Could the day be coming when the government steps in to regulate or control Google?

Ryan Avent made that case last week in The Economist, writing about what he calls “Google’s Google problem.” He argues that Google’s services and products have become so important that they’ve started to affect the way people think, plan and make decisions. “The more we all participate in this world, the more we come to depend on it,” Avent wrote. If those services were to be interrupted, they could have a negative impact on many people and, possibly, the economy. Avent argues that since we “tend not to entrust this sort of critical public infrastructure to the private sector,“ it may be inevitable that the government would step in at some point to ensure that these services continue.

But is there a chance that Google would shut down a much more widely used service than Reader, like search or Gmail? Paul Krugman makes the microeconomic theory case in The New York Times as to why it could happen. While a service like search may have a value to society that exceeds the cost of providing it, some of those benefits are due to network externalities (i.e., the more people that use it, the more valuable it becomes to everyone) and Google may not be able to properly “capture” these externalities to cover their costs.

Or, as All Things D wrote yesterday, Google may also choose to shut down services due to concerns over complying with privacy laws. These types of issues may be problematic enough that Google will only, ultimately, choose to support the services with a really large number of users. Former Google Reader product manager Nick Baum put it to All Things D this way: “My sense is, if it’s a consumer product at Google that’s not making money, unless it’s going to get to 100 million users it’s not worth doing.”

Join us:






Spotlight on ...
Online Training

    Upgrade your skills and earn higher pay

    Readers to share their best tips for maximizing training dollars and getting the most out self-directed learning. Here’s what they said.


    Learn more

IT ManagementWhite Papers & Webcasts

See more White Papers | Webcasts

Answers - Powered by ITworld

ITworld Answers helps you solve problems and share expertise. Ask a question or take a crack at answering the new questions below.

Ask a Question