Will Tumblr's seedy side turn advertisers off?

Visually interesting, and easy to use it may be, but its questionable content may turn advertisers off. What do you think?

By Tom Henderson  Add a new comment

Tumblr is an impressionistic blog, often very visual in its nature. Tumblrs are easy to form and start; compose a name, grab a theme from many offered, and start posting. Tumblrs are often composed of the gleaned posts and pieces of other Tumblrs. There are now thousands of Tumblrs and they've become addictive to some - both posting and reading. The infrastructure is analogous to platform-as-a-service, as Tumblr provides much of the support needed for many kinds of media types, and is simpler to use than even WordPress, in my opinion.

Tumblrs also have great popularity because as far as I can tell, there is no censorship of any kind. You can have beyond MySpace-like boldness, or Spartan simplicity. It's your choice of theme, and your skills at doctoring your pages after having chosen a theme. Some Tumblrs are beautiful while other pages are strictly porn, and some are actually pretty disturbing stuff. Porn often dominates the images, but math porn as well as sex porn.

There are confessionals, the studies in visual narcissisms, the serious geeks, and not a lot of MySpace-like youthful rebellion. It's gay, straight, undecided, and it's a big problem: part of the culture of Tumblr is to move graphic objects into your own Tumblr. Tumblr, like no other site I've seen, tests the Fair Use strictures of copyright law. It's a minefield where the culture is to post because it makes your Tumblr more interesting.

Wholesale copyright questions don't include music sharing that I've found, although I'm surprised that there aren't more YouTube-like DCMA takedowns. It's that part of the rawness of Tumblrs that make them more attractive to some. They're in your face, but then they're subtle. Tags are big, as are long lists of followers. Followers imply leaders, and I'll imagine that there's a way to create a taxonomy of thought-segment leadership easily. Every post leaves a trail, if not of the origin of the bits of the post, a list of people that admired it, commented on it, or stole - I mean reposted it.

Therein lies the impact of Tumblr, as it embodies the "new new" values of the web - strong sharing where reposting and amalgamation creates new objects - and potentially runs slipshod over the concept of ownership. The collaborative results can be startling. They can also pander towards the very basal in onerous ways. The temptation to share many objects within Tumblr is high because sharing is comparatively easy to other "micro-blogging" platforms and easily approachable by civilians. An increasing number of apps exist to make the job of linking and sharing more simple.

Last week, it was reported that Tumblr was close to getting between $75 and $100 in venture capital. Tumblr's revenue models could be large, and for several reasons. Currently, only savvy users have the ability to add widgets that earn them advertising revenue, usually through http_referrer clicks. Some of them lead people into the highly evolved world of porn payments. Tumblr has the possibility of allowing users to put advertising areas inside the themes associated with Tumblr, and the tracking used by Tumblr puts it in league with the data assembled by Google.

The bottom line is that Tumblr leaps over other blogging platforms, but there is a risk of being associated with the more disturbing warrens of Tumblr, and being caught up in a maelstrom of copyright issues that are unsolvable in some cases. Still, Tumblr has many of the compelling elements that made the web popular: enthusiasm, sharing, visuals, and emoting ... and strong dashes of sex.

ITworld LIVE

IT Management/StrategyWhite Papers & Webcasts

White Paper

The Cloud: Reinventing Enterprise Collaboration

Collaboration and content sharing are not, of course, new concepts. But cloud computing has changed the nature of collaboration, content sharing, document storage and project management to enable more efficient, faster-acting and cost-effective enterprises. According to a new study by IDG Research, the vast majority of knowledge workers (86%) placed a very high level of importance on collaborating with internal coworkers and external stakeholders, and having access to the most up-to-date corporate information. Read how organizations are realizing massive productivity gains by transitioning their content management solutions to cloud-based models.

White Paper

Empowering Your Mobile Worker

Today's most productive employees are mobile, and your company's IT strategy must be ready to support them with 24/7 access to the business information they need across a range of mobile devices.See how corporations are meeting the many needs of their mobile workers with the help of Box.

White Paper

Market Landscape Report: Online File Sharing and Collaboration in the Enterprise

The trend toward "consumerization" marches onward in IT; more and more end-users are choosing their own hardware plaforms and software applications in lieu of the IT-sanctioned business tools provided by their companies. These end-users are looking to tackle issues like data sharing, portability, and access from multiple intelligent endpoint devices, creating a conundrum for IT as it needs to balance business enablement, ease of access, and collaborative capacity with the need to maintain control and security of information assets. This need for balance is one of the drivers of the fast growing online file sharing and collaboration segment of the SaaS market. This paper examines the market drivers, inhibitors, and top vendors in this segment, including Box, Citrix Sharefile, Dropbox, Egnyte, Nomadesk, Sugarsync, Syncplicity and YouSendIt.

White Paper

Sharing Simplified - Consolidating File-sharing Technologies

Employees need to share content with colleagues within their organization and outside. Yet, ECMs make it hard to share content within a business and impossible between organizations. Read how one company consolidated multiple file sharing technologies to increase productivity and reduce complexity.

White Paper

Content Sharing 2.0: The Road Ahead

A growing number of companies are taking advantage of the natural synergies that exist between cloud-based IT services and content access and sharing. Legacy content management and collaboration systems simply weren't designed to meet the evolving requirements of today's IT and business managers, as well as the needs of content users. Box provides cloud-based content storage, access and collaboration services that require virtually no user training and supports file access and delivery on almost all popular PC and mobile devices. Read how Box let companies rapidly implement a cost-effective and secure content storage and sharing system that can easily expand to accommodate any size and number of files.

See more White Papers | Webcasts

Ask a question

Ask a Question