Google wants groups removed from Books lawsuits

Google told a judge that groups representing copyright holders can't seek relief for them

By Stephen Lawson, IDG News Service | IT Management/Strategy Add a new comment

December 23, 2011, 8:08 PM — Google asked a federal court to dismiss copyright claims against its Google Books project by groups representing authors and photographers on Thursday, saying the groups could not sue over copyrights they did not own.

The motion was the latest development in a legal battle that has been raging since 2005, when The Authors Guild and the American Association of Publishers sued to block Google from scanning millions of books in libraries and making digitized content from them available in libraries and online. They charge that scanning the books without always seeking permission would violate copyrights. The American Society of Media Photographers (ASMP) filed a similar lawsuit last year, which is being considered alongside the authors' case.

Google's motion seeks to remove The Authors Guild and the ASMP from the lawsuits. They don't have legal standing to sue over the copyrights because they aren't copyright holders but merely represent them, Google argued in its brief supporting the motion.

"The associations are not proper parties to this copyright infringement case because they themselves do not claim to own any copyright at issue," Google wrote in the brief to Judge Denny Chin of the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Manhattan.

Google had told Judge Chin it planned to file motions for dismissal, and the judge had set Friday as a deadline. Google did not file a similar motion to dismiss the lawsuit by the Association of American Publishers. The company is believed to be closer to reaching a settlement with the plaintiffs in that case.

Google launched the library scanning project in 2004. One copyright settlement was already reached in 2008, but Judge Chin rejected that agreement in March.

The plaintiffs will have until Jan. 23 to respond to the motions filed Thursday, and Google will then have until Feb. 3 to respond to their opposition.

Stephen Lawson covers mobile, storage and networking technologies for The IDG News Service. Follow Stephen on Twitter at @sdlawsonmedia. Stephen's e-mail address is stephen_lawson@idg.com

Stephen Lawson is a senior U.S. correspondent at IDG News Service and reports on networking (routers, switches, hubs, home networking.)

View Profile

View the discussion thread.

From CIO.com

From CSO Online

iPhone 5 growing up, but not out, this fall

10 comments
Java creator unhappy with Oracle trial outcome

5 comments
Facebook vs Google: by the numbers

3 comments
Install MATE on your Linux Mint 13 Cinnamon system

3 comments
Money, not technology, drives cloud growth, IT shrinkage

3 comments

Older
|
Newer

ITworld LIVE

The White Paper VMware Backup: 5 Misperceptions of Agentless Backup was viewed
hulucommentor has just joined ITworld
The White Paper Fair to Partly Cloudy was viewed
The White Paper Explore the Power, Flexibility and Serviceability HP ProLiant DL360p and DL380p Gen8 Servers was viewed
The White Paper Pedal to the Metal - Quickly Recover from a Data Disaster was viewed
The White Paper Protection Against the Advanced Persistent Threat was viewed
The White Paper Broker-Dealer Case Study: Reduced Compliance Burden with Perimeter's Message Archive was viewed
The White Paper Interactive eGuide: Enterprise Security was viewed
The White Paper Why AppSense for VDI: How User Virtualization performs and adds value was viewed
nshartma has just joined ITworld
Lee Tuck has just joined ITworld
The White Paper ESG: Product Brief: Quest vRanger 5.3 brings enterprise-class VMware protection to SMB's was viewed
The White Paper vRanger Helps Cut Replication Time by Almost 70% was viewed
The White Paper Virtualizing the Client - The HP Way was viewed
90Carat has just joined ITworld
freddyzdead has just joined ITworld
The Webcast Banish Poor Application Performance: Eliminate Business Disruptions, Increase End User Productivity was viewed
Managed IT Services has just joined ITworld
The White Paper Accelerate Virtualized Results: HP VirtualSystem VS1 for VMware was viewed
dlgmex@gmail.com has just joined ITworld
The White Paper Forrester Report: The ROI of Cloud Apps was viewed
mimimimi has just joined ITworld
Irata has just joined ITworld
amgulab has just joined ITworld
The White Paper IDC Vendor Spotlight was viewed
The White Paper Fair to Partly Cloudy was viewed
texlux has just joined ITworld
Pedro has just joined ITworld
The White Paper The Cost Advantages of Using a Hosted Unified Communications Service: A TCO Guide for SMBs was viewed
The White Paper Aberdeen Analyst Insight: Does Your Enterprise Have a Dropbox Problem? was viewed

IT Management/StrategyWhite Papers & Webcasts

White Paper

The Cloud: Reinventing Enterprise Collaboration

Collaboration and content sharing are not, of course, new concepts. But cloud computing has changed the nature of collaboration, content sharing, document storage and project management to enable more efficient, faster-acting and cost-effective enterprises. According to a new study by IDG Research, the vast majority of knowledge workers (86%) placed a very high level of importance on collaborating with internal coworkers and external stakeholders, and having access to the most up-to-date corporate information. Read how organizations are realizing massive productivity gains by transitioning their content management solutions to cloud-based models.

White Paper

Empowering Your Mobile Worker

Today's most productive employees are mobile, and your company's IT strategy must be ready to support them with 24/7 access to the business information they need across a range of mobile devices.See how corporations are meeting the many needs of their mobile workers with the help of Box.

White Paper

Market Landscape Report: Online File Sharing and Collaboration in the Enterprise

The trend toward "consumerization" marches onward in IT; more and more end-users are choosing their own hardware plaforms and software applications in lieu of the IT-sanctioned business tools provided by their companies. These end-users are looking to tackle issues like data sharing, portability, and access from multiple intelligent endpoint devices, creating a conundrum for IT as it needs to balance business enablement, ease of access, and collaborative capacity with the need to maintain control and security of information assets. This need for balance is one of the drivers of the fast growing online file sharing and collaboration segment of the SaaS market. This paper examines the market drivers, inhibitors, and top vendors in this segment, including Box, Citrix Sharefile, Dropbox, Egnyte, Nomadesk, Sugarsync, Syncplicity and YouSendIt.

White Paper

Sharing Simplified - Consolidating File-sharing Technologies

Employees need to share content with colleagues within their organization and outside. Yet, ECMs make it hard to share content within a business and impossible between organizations. Read how one company consolidated multiple file sharing technologies to increase productivity and reduce complexity.

White Paper

Content Sharing 2.0: The Road Ahead

A growing number of companies are taking advantage of the natural synergies that exist between cloud-based IT services and content access and sharing. Legacy content management and collaboration systems simply weren't designed to meet the evolving requirements of today's IT and business managers, as well as the needs of content users. Box provides cloud-based content storage, access and collaboration services that require virtually no user training and supports file access and delivery on almost all popular PC and mobile devices. Read how Box let companies rapidly implement a cost-effective and secure content storage and sharing system that can easily expand to accommodate any size and number of files.

See more White Papers | Webcasts