Will Do Not Track kill the 'free' Internet?

That's what some folks believe, anyway. I think that argument is wrong. Here's why.


I got some interesting reactions to my last post about Abine’s Do Not Track Plus utility. In a nutshell: Without the benefits brought by online tracking, the “free” Internet will cease to exist.

I want to address some of those concerns here, but first, let’s get one thing straight: For me and the 1 billion+ people who access the Web on a daily basis, the Internet is hardly “free.” Adding up the costs of access at home, at my office, and for various mobile devices for my family of four, I spend more than $200 a month for “free” Internet.

Yes, I understand, that money is going to ISPs, not content providers. But to me, Joe Consumer, the Internet isn’t all that much different than cable TV: I pay a certain amount each month to get mostly ad-supported content delivered to me. I don’t give a damn about how CNN or AMC or MSNBC make their money, their business models, who pays how much to whom for what, yadda yadda; all I care about is what my cable bill costs each month.

But the Internet costs much more than cable TV, and not just in terms of pure dollars. It costs me my privacy. Because Web ads know far more about me than TV commercials do. They know which other ads I’ve seen as I surf, and they know which ads I may have responded to. They also know what “channels” I’ve watched (i.e., sites I’ve visited), and depending on the ad network, they might also know my IP address, my city, the things I’ve searched for, and more. And once they collect this information, they can do anything they want with it. There are no rules.

In the ad biz this is called Behavioral Targeting. You and I know this better as Web Tracking. Now Behavioral Targeting/Web Tracking is not necessarily evil. But it’s another way I pay for online access, and it happens automatically without my prior consent.

There are a lot of moving parts to this debate, which I can’t tackle in a single blog post. But to grossly oversimplify: Advertisers and their cronies argue that a) online tracking is totally anonymous and thus not a threat, and b) without targeted advertising, the “free” Internet will go away. Privacy advocates argue that a) tracking isn’t quite as anonymous as advertisers claim, and b) consumers who don’t want their movements tracked online have a right to Just Say No.

Join us:






IT ManagementWhite Papers & Webcasts

See more White Papers | Webcasts

Answers - Powered by ITworld

ITworld Answers helps you solve problems and share expertise. Ask a question or take a crack at answering the new questions below.

Ask a Question