European Commission pushing ACTA through the backdoor?

Yes, say civil liberties groups. No, say politicians.

By Jennifer Baker, IDG News Service |  IT Management

Digital civil liberties groups on Tuesday said that a trade deal being thrashed out between Europe and Canada is
an attempt to introduce the controversial anti-piracy agreement ACTA by the back door.

Leaked documents have shown that the part of the text of the Canada-EU Trade Agreement (CETA) that relates to
intellectual property rights enforcement is almost identical to ACTA. Also, it's a little-known deal that is being
conducted behind closed doors, which sounds strikingly familiar to those who protested against ACTA.

"The worst and most damaging parts for our freedoms online are word for word the same in ACTA and CETA. This
trick to bring back ACTA through the backdoor is in line with Trade Commissioner De Gucht's declaration after the
vote on July 4, that he has no consideration whatsoever for citizens and the Parliament and is just the copyright
lobbies' lapdog. CETA must be opposed and defeated, just like ACTA," said J鲩mie Zimmermann, co-founder of La
Quadrature du Net, in a statement.

But is this really an attempt by the European Commission, which negotiates such deals, to override the European
Parliament's decision last week to reject ACTA? Leading member of Parliament Marietje Schaake says no.

"I am concerned about some of the alarmist emails I have received already," said Schaake. "This deal, although
the text is indeed a copy and paste from the ACTA agreement, is not a backdoor attempt by the Commission, since the
current draft was drawn up before ACTA was thrown out. At the time the Commission still anticipated that ACTA would
be passed."

Even Pirate Party founder Rick Falkvinge, a vocal opponent of ACTA, also pointed out on his blog that CETA was
drafted long before the European Parliament voted against ACTA. The Commission assumed that ACTA would be
rubber-stamped he said. "This was more than a reasonable assumption from the European Commission in February 2012;
it was even the way I would have expected them to do their job, whether I liked it or not," added Falkvinge.

CETA is still in the early stages and will not be put before the European Parliament until the beginning of
2014. The text leaked this week dates from February. In the meantime there will be the usual legal checks and text
revisions.

"It's too early to say this is a new ACTA. If the Commission is wise, it will modify the chapter before it comes
before the Parliament or I see no reason why the same concerns wouldn't be raised," said Schaake. In this sense the
fact that the two deals are so similar could be interpreted as good news for opponents of ACTA.

Join us:
Facebook

Twitter

Pinterest

Tumblr

LinkedIn

Google+

Answers - Powered by ITworld

ITworld Answers helps you solve problems and share expertise. Ask a question or take a crack at answering the new questions below.

Join us:
Facebook

Twitter

Pinterest

Tumblr

LinkedIn

Google+

Ask a Question