iPhone-themed anti-AT&T whining: Some justified, some not

By Josh Fruhlinger  1 comment

One thing you learn when following tech developments is that people are whiny. Well, you probably learn that just by interacting with human beings generally, but the class of people who are especially attuned to the latest and greatest tech advances are especially whiny if things don't go their way. Though people with money to burn on gadgets are more or less by definition among the most well-off inhabitants in the most well-off societies in the world, when any new gizmos come down the pipe, a certain subset will react with outrage, suddenly discovering anew that the companies that manufacture the things are in it to make money. You get lots of anguished cries of "crippled" and "screwed" and "slap in the face." You'd think that the stuff sucker-punches you in the gut when it comes out of the box.

If you're inside the cult like me, you generally feel compelled to not launch these attacks at Apple (well, except when they come out with a new laptop RIGHT AFTER you bought yours SPECIFICALLY TO MAKE YOU MISERABLE, but you feel bad about complaining afterwards). But Apple fans feel no compunctions about channeling their ire at AT&T for everything annoying about the iPhone experience in the U.S. At WWDC Monday, Apple practically encouraged it, showcasing the fact that the MMS and tethering features built into iPhone OS 3.0 will be available immediately in many countries, but "at the end of the summer" and "when we get around to it" here in Apple's home base.

And in truth, AT&T ought to be slammed on these points. The MMS delay is kind of unfathomable, as multimedia messaging ought by rights to be a cash cow; the tethering thing is something that users have wanted for years -- and which has been possible with jailbroken iPhones pretty much from the beginning -- and so the delay on that is particularly galling. I'm willing to bet that AT&T's foot-dragging here is largely due to their creaking network. They probably need to do some last-minute jiggering to get MMS to work properly without overwhelming the works with endless 300 KB pics of cute kitties or whatever. When it comes to tethering, well, I have bad news for you: it's going to cost you. I know linear geek logic says "I have unlimited Internet access through the phone now, therefore I should be able to use that unlimited access how I choose"; but it's only possible for AT&T to offer you that unlimited access on its current network because it knows you won't use it the way you would if, say, you had a computer with unlimited access. Charging for tethering serves multiple purposes: it makes them money which they can (if they're smart) reinvest in their network, and it cuts down on the number of people using said network, until that network is spruced up. The real thing to whine about here is that it isn't ready now; surely Apple let AT&T know well in advance that tethering was coming, and it would have been smart to have pricing plans good to go on June 19th.

But the whining that really baffles my mind involves pricing, and long-term contracts. My wife and I got our iPhones last September; since I'm a normal, lazy human with a life, I obviously didn't read the fine print on the contract, but I came away pretty firm in the knowledge that I was locked into AT&T and my phone for two years. I did this in full knowledge that a newer, shinier gadget would come down the pike during that time. And so, on Monday, when I saw the new 3GS demoed, I shook my head ruefully and vowed to find someone who had one and ask to play with it, some day.

You know what I didn't do? Start a thread on the AT&T support forums demanding that I get a discount price on the 3GS! That's because, when I plopped down $199 apiece for those phones, I knew that AT&T was giving Apple substantially more than that; in return I agreed to be locked in for the next 24 months. It's a pretty straightforward transaction, if not entirely transparent. Expecting a large multinational publicly traded corporation to sell me another phone at subsidized prices a few months later because I'm "loyal" is the height of lunacy, and shows a fundamental misunderstanding of How The World Works.

Don't take this to mean that I'm thrilled with AT&T; come September 2010, the possibility of, say, Verizon support for the iPhone to come might give me pause. But my lust for an iPhone 3GS is just that -- standard-issued gadget lust. It is not embittered by outrage over corporate injustice.

Follow Josh on Google+

Josh Fruhlinger is ITworld's associate online news editor.

1 comment

    marisal
    marisal 2 years ago
    Good points! Like somebody in the thread you referenced said, if you bought a different phone two months ago, you wouldn't expect to get a break on iPhone pricing. My iPhone lust is at an even further remove. After a bad customer service experience with AT&T, I refuse to use them. So I'm waiting for the iPhone to jump ship to T-Mobile where I will cheerfully spend way more than I should for a phone.Till then, my Treo 650 (bought on eBay for $50) will have to satisfy.

      Add a comment

      Post a comment using one of these accounts
      Or join now
      At least 6 characters

      Note: Comment will appear soon after you have activated your account.
      Obscene/spam comments will be removed and accounts suspended.
      The information you submit is subject to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.

      ITworld LIVE

      Mobile & WirelessWhite Papers & Webcasts

      White Paper

      Ten Steps to an Enterprise Mobility Strategy

      Enterprise employees are more mobile, relishing the ability to work productively anywhere, at any time. They may use any means to get connected, often creating financial and security risks for your company. Discover how to get control of your enterprise mobility strategy and ensure mobile worker productivity with these ten steps.

      White Paper

      What You Need to Know About the Costs of Mobility

      Mobile workers want to get connected anywhere, at any time, often at any cost. Enterprise mobility is often a hidden "black" budget in your company. Ensure that your traveling employees are productive everywhere, even while you control cost and security, through an enterprise mobility strategy.

      White Paper

      The 2011 iPass Mobile Enterprise Report

      This industry survey covers trends, recommendations and a policy guide on managing Enterprise Mobility for IT management and CIOs. Get data on employee device liability, as well as smartphone/tablet penetration, budget control and provisioning. Find out how your organization compares, how to ensure mobile worker productivity, and control costs.

      Webcast On Demand

      Managing Enterprise Mobility Costs

      Mobile employees, especially those traveling internationally, were spending time and resources finding and making connections. Roaming costs were out of control. The IT Administrator at The Hay Group tells you how he got more control over these costs, providing management with predictable budgets and insights while ensuring employee productivity.

      Sponsor: iPass

      White Paper

      Digital Transformation: Creating New Business Models Where Digital Meets Physical

      Individuals and businesses alike are embracing the digital revolution. Social networks and digital devices are being used to engage government, businesses and civil society, as well as friends and family.

      See more White Papers | Webcasts

      Ask a question

      Ask a Question