Vindication! iPhone to stay on AT&T, forever

By Josh Fruhlinger  13 comments

Yes, I know: you all really want a Verizon version of the iPhone in the U.S. Who doesn't? Heck, with all the unprofitable pressure the iPhone puts on AT&T's data network, probably even AT&T would like some help bearing the load of all those data-hungry iPhone users at this point. Well, surprise! It looks like Apple and AT&T are going to recommit to their troubled marriage.

This is all according not to anyone at Apple or AT&T, but to some analyst at iSuppi Corp., but like all tech writers, I'm happy to quote analysts when they agree with what I already believe, and, of course, I already believe that Apple is stuck with AT&T in the medium term. The gist of iSuppli's analysis is that the iPhone is a global product, and the HSPA standard used by AT&T is more widely used than the EVDO standard used by Verizon, and the gap is growing. There are fancy charts that prove this -- or, you know, you could just listen to what Apple has been explicitly saying on the subject, though that doesn't get you fancy analyst points the way that drawing charts does, I guess.

To stave off the inevitable griping about how terrible AT&T is, my goal here is not to defend their service; it's merely to point out what I keep pointing out, which is that Apple, in choosing to make a single phone model for the de facto global standard, has little choice than to stick with what they've got. At best, they could forego exclusivity and also sell their phones with T-Mobile, but since T-Mobile is at this point sort of an also-ran, the most minor of the major wireless carriers, that wouldn't shake the system up very much. The only way the iPhone-on-Verizon scenario comes about in the near future is if Apple changes tactics and makes a second, CDMA-compatible version of the iPhone. Which isn't impossible or anything, but it's much more complicated than just signing a new contract with a different wireless carrier.

Of course, Verizon will be rolling out a new, GSM-compatible 4G network over the next few years, but that probably won't be omnipresent enough to justify GSM-only phones on Verizon until 2013 or so. And four years is an absolute eternity in tech time. By the time 2013 rolls around, the iPhone as we know it will have become something else entirely (or more likely several somethings else entirely) and the terms of this debate will be very different. That's why I stuck "forever" on the title of this post. 2013 might as well be an eternity away.

Follow Josh on Google+

Josh Fruhlinger is ITworld's associate online news editor.

13 comments

    Anonymous 2 years ago
    Verizon is the worst phone company in the USA.apple should definitely stay with AT&T
    Anonymous 2 years ago
    Winter is coming, you and your families still have no ugg boots? Just a problem, Sheepskin boots like ugg classic tall boots is the necessity in the cold witer. Especially in the snow space, ugg classic short boots will keep you warm and safe. At the same time, somebody may say, all of the ugg snow boots, the ugg classic cardy bootsis the best choice. Some online stores also sell these ugg boots at low price, so come on now.
    links
    links 2 years ago
    These collected, made by some experienced goldsmith and silversmith,links of london bracelet are extremely exquisite, peculiar, and classic. Mostly they are the key to jewellery box, links of london braceletcollection box, album, diary, luggage, and even the door of a private club or a country manor.links of london bracelet However, the “amulet” with magic color is now developed into links of london keys series and the old stories also find new places and explanations throughlinks of london bracelet the or the necklaces of links of london.
    Anonymous 2 years ago
    As much as I'd love to have an iPhone. AT&T in our area is so bad two people standing side by side in the local mall will get dropped calls if calling each other.
    Anonymous 2 years ago
    Verizon is working to get a 4G LTE network running in 1Q 2010 in select areas. There will be no CDMA iPhone, it doesn't make sense to build a phone that will be obsolete before it hits the market. Both AT&T and Verizon are both going to 4G LTE. Before 4Q 2010, there will be a Verizon iPhone on LTE and Forever will be gone.
    Anonymous 2 years ago
    Love the article dude. Great tone and better writing.I do have one thought.. I'm one of those people that are very formal, plan everything out, etc, but then go take a silly gamble. Which usually works. :DThought is, it's possible that T-Mobile could use the iPhone as a boost, get it into the big leagues. Yes, it's currently too small to make a sizeable impact on the network load, but the income it would recieve from the iPhone if it were allowed access, would be enough to boost it's size considerably. If it started by taking out loans, then building up it's coverage and access in major cities and releasing a limited amount of iPhones (given the current condition of AT&T's network, demand would be high for an alternative option, giving a limited amount means that they would quickly sell out and also keep the network load down). Then using the money from the iPhones/access they sold, and they would definitely sell, they can increase coverage further, open up more spots, then start expanding to other areas.If it were managed right, in the time it takes Verizon to roll out it's new network, T-Mobile could mean that iPhone users wouldn't dream of leaving.A gamble, but one that has a fairly high chance of working. Theoretically at least.
    Anonymous 2 years ago
    Perhaps you have forgotten about Verizon's (and AT&T's) planned migration from CDMA to LTE beginning next year. Obviously Apple will need to develop an iPhone that will work with this new standard. I do realize the migration to the new technology will not occur overnight, but all the same I think it would be fair to say that Verizon will be carrying the iPhone sooner rather than later.
    jfruh
    jfruh 2 years ago in reply to Anonymous
    Actually, I mentioned said migration in the article itself. Rollout will being in 2010, but only in a few select cities. Verizon will not sell a phone that will only work in four or five urban areas -- any phones they sell will have to be compatible with both their new network and their old one, which the current iPhone is not. 2013 is probably earliest we can expect to see 4G coverage wide enough to reasonably sell GSM-only phones.
    Anonymous 2 years ago
    "one analyst firm is PREDICTING AT&T's exclusive deal as the wireless carrier will be extended beyond then."This is NOT a done deal by any stretch of the imagination.
    Anonymous 2 years ago
    Are you serious. Apple has some of the most talented and smartest engineers out there and plenty of pull to get a CDMA chip for a phone. They have plenty of pull in the industry to get the parts at the price they want. Its all about the bottom line.$$$$$$$$$$MONEY$$$$$$$$$$ If AT&T pays enough that it covers the millions of iPhones that they could sell on Verizon then thats the ways it will be. If not then there will be a Verizon iPhone thats CDMA/LTE compatible because thats gonna be very profitable! AND VERY FAST!
    Anonymous 2 years ago in reply to Anonymous
    there has been lots of chatter that Apple has already hired people profficiant in cdma... go check the apple equivalent to want ads for earlier this year
    Anonymous 2 years ago
    This, of course, is assuming that the continued exclusivity is deemed legal.
    Anonymous 2 years ago in reply to Anonymous
    You must be a obama communist. If a company makes a good product and everyone buys it, you whine about anti trust. It's not anti trust moron, you have a choice, buy another phone? if your logic was used, then every good product would be cause for anti trust.

      Add a comment

      Post a comment using one of these accounts
      Or join now
      At least 6 characters

      Note: Comment will appear soon after you have activated your account.
      Obscene/spam comments will be removed and accounts suspended.
      The information you submit is subject to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.

      ITworld LIVE

      Mobile & WirelessWhite Papers & Webcasts

      White Paper

      Ten Steps to an Enterprise Mobility Strategy

      Enterprise employees are more mobile, relishing the ability to work productively anywhere, at any time. They may use any means to get connected, often creating financial and security risks for your company. Discover how to get control of your enterprise mobility strategy and ensure mobile worker productivity with these ten steps.

      White Paper

      What You Need to Know About the Costs of Mobility

      Mobile workers want to get connected anywhere, at any time, often at any cost. Enterprise mobility is often a hidden "black" budget in your company. Ensure that your traveling employees are productive everywhere, even while you control cost and security, through an enterprise mobility strategy.

      White Paper

      The 2011 iPass Mobile Enterprise Report

      This industry survey covers trends, recommendations and a policy guide on managing Enterprise Mobility for IT management and CIOs. Get data on employee device liability, as well as smartphone/tablet penetration, budget control and provisioning. Find out how your organization compares, how to ensure mobile worker productivity, and control costs.

      Webcast On Demand

      Managing Enterprise Mobility Costs

      Mobile employees, especially those traveling internationally, were spending time and resources finding and making connections. Roaming costs were out of control. The IT Administrator at The Hay Group tells you how he got more control over these costs, providing management with predictable budgets and insights while ensuring employee productivity.

      Sponsor: iPass

      White Paper

      Digital Transformation: Creating New Business Models Where Digital Meets Physical

      Individuals and businesses alike are embracing the digital revolution. Social networks and digital devices are being used to engage government, businesses and civil society, as well as friends and family.

      See more White Papers | Webcasts

      Ask a question

      Ask a Question