Opinion: Your XP-to-Windows 7 upgrade path: Buy a new PC

By Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols, Computerworld |  Operating Systems, Windows 7 Add a new comment

Microsoft's leaders really, really want you to forget about Vista and move right on to Windows 7. And who can blame them? Vista was a train wreck. No one who knows what they're doing runs Vista, not even the Microsoft faithful. Windows 7, on the other hand, is a worthwhile desktop operating system. There's only one little problem. There's no good way to get from XP to 7.

Actually, that's not a small problem at all. According to Net Applications' Market Share report , in August 2009, 71.7% of all desktops were running XP, compared to a mere 18.8% running Vista. So, that means the great majority of Windows users will have to try to migrate from XP to 7.

I use the word "migrate" deliberately instead of "update" or "upgrade" because this will be a migration. If you are among the small minority using Vista, you can upgrade to 7 without any fuss or muss, so long as the move is between equivalent versions, like Vista Home Premium and Windows 7 Home Premium, or you're jumping up, to Windows 7 Ultimate, for example.

I only wish that were the case for XP. The only way you can get from XP to Windows 7 is to do a clean install . Period. End of statement.

And, what's involved with a clean install, you ask? It means you erase every last program and file on your hard disk during the "upgrade." Ow.

You can save some of it. Microsoft's Windows Easy Transfer , which comes in Windows 7, will let you save your files and your settings. Of course, some of those settings may not work anymore with Windows 7, but that's a relatively minor pain.

The major headache is that you can't transfer your old programs and device drivers from XP to Windows 7. So, do you know where your install disk is for Quicken 2008? How about Office 2003? Or, for that matter, do you really want to download iTunes and Firefox, plus a half-dozen must-have Firefox extensions, all over again? Well, you'd better know what you have on your current XP system, and you'd better be ready to reinstall them all and reset them to just the way you like them, because that's exactly what you're going to need to do.

For an individual, that's annoying. It took me two or three hours, but I'm always installing and updating operating systems. Microsoft estimates that heavy users , people with 125GB of data and 40 applications, would need between 2 hours and 40 minutes and 5 hours and 43 minutes to upgrade their systems. A super user could take close to 20 hours But, wait, those Microsoft numbers are for Vista to Windows 7! XP to Windows 7 can only take much longer. At best, I suspect we're looking at it taking a full day for heavy users to make the migration. Now, imagine multiplying that by a business's dozens to tens of thousands of PCs. That's not just a headache; it's the kind of major suffering that companies try to avoid whenever humanly possible.

Let's say you have 100 PCs in your business running XP and you want to move them to Windows 7. Let's assume that it will take eight hours per PC to do the job. Using the Bureau of Labor Statistics' hourly wage numbers for computer support specialists from May 2008 , the latest numbers that are available, the total cost of the labor needed to complete the upgrade process would be $17,832.

I'm presuming, of course, that your business is using a standardized software package and that you have all the program install disks at hand. If you don't, your bill is going to be much, much higher.

And of course, you have to add to your bill the licensing fees for Windows 7. While Linux upgrades are free and Mac OS Snow Leopard costs $29 for Leopard users, you'll need to pay a pretty penny for Windows 7 . If you upgrade from, say, Windows Vista Business to Windows 7 Professional, it will cost you $199 per PC. I presume that Microsoft will offer a similar deal to XP Pro users. If not, it will run you $299 retail for Win 7 Pro. But let's assume Microsoft is going to cut you some slack. Still, our 100-PC company has to shell out nearly 20 grand, $19,900, for its Win 7 licenses.

1 comment

    Anonymous 2 years ago
    OK, lets assume we need to upgrade 100 business desktops. All with between 5 and 10 customized / departmental applications. Add to that, all of the apps, documents and email, etc of 100 users and; according to our author, this is IT h*ll. With an IT staff with no REAL WORLD experience... expect this to be the case. Aside from the licensing "insanity", and his bizarre budget calculations (business licensing-mate), he's spot on. In bizarro world....A few buzzwords and such for ya, Steve: Ghost, drive imaging, roaming profiles, industrial strength drive duplication equipment, full user profiles from your currently - hopefully stable network, replacing the old user's pc hard disk with an imaged disk - ready to import the specific user's data, SMS server, MOM server, etc. All of these things would add together to make the process to migrate a user approximately a 20 minute venture per pc; well... plus all of the time of the rollout developement cycle. Please don't think I'm not considering all of the millions of hours of testings all of the major depart's "major apps". Thats another topic alltogether. We are talking simpified desktop deployment. Its a BASIC tenet of the whole idea of Microshaft.Mind you, I'm writing this using Firefox on Ubuntu 9.04 - I might know my Microsoft (15 + years experience, and certs from the NT days), but I'm older and wiser and have my own company now. Wax on wax off young student. Think outside the box - and overall, don't panic... EVER! Your problem (ANY PROBLEM)has been encountered before, and someone; somewhere has posted a solution online. Google is your friend. Forget the books and remember your street smarts. Your article has an "I'm scared" undertone all over it, and if a potential customer saw it, at least I would run. Dunno about anyone else.Unfortunately, it is BOOKSMART and NOT BATTLEFIELDSMART that companies are getting now. This was not meant to insult you, or anybody - but to just be a "commentary". I did not mean to do a soapbox kind of thing, but if this is whats going to be the future of my country, then we're fubar - ed, and I had to say something.Hang in there,Cybertech

      Add a comment

      Post a comment using one of these accounts
      Or join now
      At least 6 characters

      Note: Comment will appear soon after you have activated your account.
      Obscene/spam comments will be removed and accounts suspended.
      The information you submit is subject to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.

      ITworld LIVE

      Operating SystemsWhite Papers & Webcasts

      White Paper

      Microsoft Enterprise Agreement Program Overview

      Discover how flexible the Microsoft Enterprise Agreement Program is to help you build the right software solution agreement for your business. This paper highlights all the available options-from on-premise software and cloud service solutions, to payment options and enrollment programs, and more.

      White Paper

      Watson - A System Designed for Answers. The future of workload optimized systems design

      Watson is a workload optimized system designed for complex analytics, made possible by integrating massively parallel POWER7 processors and DeepQA technology. Read the white paper about Watson's workload optimized system design.

      See more White Papers | Webcasts

      Ask a question

      Ask a Question