Are Macs the mainstay or the bonus?

By Josh Fruhlinger  6 comments

Market research firm NPD put out a study earlier this week about the market penetration of various PC brands, which was full of all sorts of interesting information, but the one that was most interesting to me was that almost 85 percent of households with Macs also have at least one Windows PC. (And no, the reverse is not also true.)

The question, of course, is what this might mean. If you're a Mac hater, I'm guessing your first response would be that Macs are toys, and that you need a PC if you want to get real work done. While my take on it is obviously more Applephilic, I will admit that my household is in that 85 percent for exactly that reason: for quite a while, some of my freelance clients required me to work with Web applications that only worked in IE on Windows, and my Macs at the time just weren't powerful enough to run Virtual PC (yes, this was pre-Intel) in a meaningful way.

The legacy of this era is that I now have two computers: a year-old MacBook and a creaky five-year-old IBM (yes, IBM!) ThinkPad. Of course, in these days of Web standards, nobody makes use a Windows/IE app any more, and if they did, I could just install Parallels for a lot less than buying a Windows computer. But I do have a wife, and we do like to be online at the same time, so the ThinkPad is still well-used, even if it is getting pretty long in the tooth.

And that brings up the next question, relevant to these numbers: what do we replace it with? Of course, I'd love to get a unibody MacBook Pro (the kind that was introduced mere weeks after I bought my current laptop) to use as my main computer and demote the current MacBook to secondary status. But that would be spendy. The cheaper thing to do, of course, would be to get a Windows laptop. Yes, I know, foaming Mac fanboys: same price for identical performance, blah blah blah; you don't have to convince me. But the thing is, there really is an entry-level $500-600 laptop slot that simply doesn't exist in the Mac marketplace; but that's all we really need for our secondary computer, seeing as all it gets used for is Web surfing and occasional light word processing. Thus, I'm convinced that in many modern-day households, the Windows computer is a less powerful (and cheaper) secondary computer, whereas the Mac is the workhorse.

But maybe I'm extrapolating too much from my own experience. What's it like in your house?

Follow Josh on Google+

Josh Fruhlinger is ITworld's associate online news editor.

6 comments

    Anonymous 2 years ago
    Back when I was getting started professionally our pros used Macs for graphics, Suns for development/engineering/research and the boss used the PC for porn. Later as Mac market share fell I noticed the pros just held on to their beloved macs as did I since I was support. The Boss held onto his PC and was determined to save money so the computational folks dropped Suns for PC's with Red Hat. Now the Boss has a Mac because his 15 year old showed him her iPod 4 years ago and a PC because his old old QuickBooks & Quicken files won't translate to the Mac, the Graphics people have bought new macs which they intend to hold on to for 10 yrs minimum and the computational people have linux in the racks and Macs on their desktops. So from my perspective Windows PC's have always been second class computers.
    Anonymous 2 years ago
    A tweaked ubuntu is more fun than a mac and even cheaper than a Windows PC. The best things in life are free.
    Anonymous 2 years ago
    When I did the switch 2 years ago, I dumped all three of my Dells onto friends and relatives. Never had a problem since. At work, I'm still forced to use them and I grow tired of all the crap. The more Windows updates itself, the more goes wrong. But it does get friendlier about telling you what the problem is you can do nothing about.
    claird
    claird 2 years ago

    While I assume Naked Bunny already realizes this, I'll document it for others who might be reading the thread: Mac OS has built in a thoroughly usable RDP client for at least four years. In my office right now are three open laptops. The Mac is the oldest. It's the one I use for RDP.

    I entirely agree that large swathes of computing life amount to use of terminals or slightly-glorified variants.

    Anonymous 2 years ago
    I've been self employed for about 17 years and have never had a PC. The old cliches about PC's being for professionals and Macs for amateurs etc.. have never been true for me. My MacBook Pro handles even the most memory hogging applications around. I'll admit that the price a Mac sucks compared to what a PC cost, but it is made up for in productivity and ease of use. I currently have 12 Apple products in my house and am bummed that I ever sold my Apple stock.
    Anonymous 2 years ago
    imac, ibook never owned a PC never will.

      Add a comment

      Post a comment using one of these accounts
      Or join now
      At least 6 characters

      Note: Comment will appear soon after you have activated your account.
      Obscene/spam comments will be removed and accounts suspended.
      The information you submit is subject to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.

      ITworld LIVE

      Ask a question

      Ask a Question