MSI ready to launch iPad alternative

By Peter Smith  17 comments

So we get it, a lot of you are underwhelmed by the iPad. But there's much more to the tablet world than Apple's latest creation. According to Digitimes (via Engadget), MSI's 10" tablet is coming during the second half of 2010. But will you Doubting Thomases be any happier with this offering?

[ Get news and reviews on tech toys in ITworld's personal tech newsletter]

The price is the same as the cheapest iPad ($500) and the capacitive screen is effectively the same size (9.7" for the iPad, 10" for the MSI). The iPad runs iPhone OS while the MSI runs Android. That means the MSI will multitask of course, and Flash support in Android should be a given by launch time (though that isn't certain). It has a camera. It's running on an Nvidia Tegra2 chip which Ars Technica suggests puts it on par with the iPad's A4 as far as computing horsepower. And of course Android doesn't live in a walled garden.

On the other hand, it doesn't have the iTunes App Store, nor does it have the media partners that Apple has lined up for the iPad. And (as seen in the video below) native apps don't support multi-touch pinch and zoom gestures.

So what do you say, iPad doubters? Is a device like this any more appealing or will you still stick to your smartphones and netbooks? (Another intriguing option is the Notion Ink Adam which Engadget took a good look at during CES.)

Some of you, I know, just aren't interested in the tablet form factor but others have specific grievances with the iPad in particular, and I'm wondering if a device that addresses some of these grievances without increasing the price is of more interest.

Here's one of the least bad videos of the MSI Android Tablet that I could find at YouTube, so you can see it in action. Keep in mind it isn't shipping for at least 5 months so in theory response should get a bit snappier, and rough edges should get a bit of polishing, before then.

Follow Peter on Google+

Peter Smith writes about personal technology for ITworld.

17 comments

    seanb209
    seanb209 27 weeks ago
    This was the same price as the Ipad? I've never even heard of MSI before and they tablet priced as Ipad. Hmm, Ipad vs Msi for $500, which shall I chose? Duh, the Ipad of course. Personally I'm a netbook fan so I'll stick with my sylvania netbook for now.
    Anonymous 51 weeks ago
    I look forward to this. Competition makes progress. Although I like to download ebooks for ipad now.
    Anonymous 1 year ago
    OK looks/sounds great by the specs... but that video should be called iPad alternative CONCEPT."not enough memory to load photo" ... ?I must say I would much rather have a tablet running Android, for obvious reasons, but this was underwhelming.
    Anonymous 1 year ago
    I don't know if it is due to a limitation of the video card hardware or just plain old incompetent programming, but the touch response on everything that's not an iGadget is consistently horrifying. It's so jittery that it's an insult to every capacitive touch screen that's been made.I have a Palm Pre and just like the MSI it too often has the same brain damaged screen response. Is it really so hard to observe and copy this simple but critical aspect into all Apple-wannabe touchscreen products?
    Anonymous 1 year ago
    Oohh..it's a lil bit sluggish. i wait for the iSlate. Windows 7 is better than Android.
    Anonymous 2 years ago
    why is it a bad thing to lack itunes and iphone apps? It runs on android. It has flash. It will have access to a whole world of open source software that the iPad could only dream of.
    Anonymous 2 years ago
    With all that real estate on the back of these gadgets, a solar array for battery charging would seem like a natural.
    Anonymous 2 years ago
    I really like the concept of an Android tablet alternative, but judging by the video the scrolling seems kind of sluggish. Anything that runs on a tablet form factor should be absolutely smooth.
    Anonymous 2 years ago
    Not that these all aren't really cool gadgets, but personally I'm not really interested until these things start getting full blown Operating Systems. If it doesn't fit in my pocket then it's going to have to compete with my laptop for backpack space, and my laptop just does alot more...I can see this type of thing really cutting down on the learning curve for non-tech-saavy users, I think I just happen to be tech saavy enough to put a laptop to good use.
    pasmith
    pasmith 2 years ago in reply to Anonymous
    So for you, the HP Slate perhaps?I worry about Windows 7 and touch. My MT91 is pretty fussy when it come to touch, but it isn't a capacitive screen either, so that might be a lot of the problem.
    Anonymous 2 years ago
    Yep, battery life is very important for a travel companion...But it must also be able to act as hub for digital gadgetry while on the move, and do skype videoconferencing (not do much of videocall at home, but a lot when abroad if wifi is available), which are imho the big failures of the iPad.In my case what I'd like: at least 1 USB host, 2 better so that I can -sync my smartphone -copy movie/pics from my digicam -backup everything on a usb hdd if internal storage is not enough (32 GB is not enough if you have a fullHD digicam) an SD slot to increase internal storage. slightly smaller, 7-8'' would be the sweet spot - else I would take the extra thickness of a tegra2 netbook just to get a usable keyboard...Without that, it is simply not compelling compared to a netbook+smartphone while on the move, desktop/beefy laptop + TV + mediacenter + smartphone at home...
    Anonymous 2 years ago
    While it may have a better hardware mix, based on the video it seems far behind the elegance of the iPad. If this won't come out until at least 6 months after the iPad, I feel they will be behind the power curve. I'm sure Apple will not be sitting still and will have other offerings not long after sales begin, like iPhone OS 4.0 which will hopefully address most of the software shortcomings.Not that I'm interested in the iPad either. Just saying...
    Anonymous 2 years ago in reply to Anonymous
    I'm confused. Exactly what is the "elegance" of the iPad of which you speak? From what I can say the iPad's OS and interface is just as underwhelming as the iPhones, no multi-tasking and the menu system is comprised of nice looking icons on multiple pages, or the menu bar at the bottom, or am I missing something more "elegant?" Seems to me from the demo above that Android is a lot MORE elegant if anything, especially considering it will multi-task out of the box (as would Windows 7 based tablets) and be an open platform.Don't get me wrong, I love my iPhone, but the ONLY reason I'm using it is because of the available apps now and hardware compatability, eventually it's going to be passed in feature capabilities by Android and Windows 7 based machines I have no doubt. The Apple hardware is slick but it's also very "locked down".
    Anonymous 2 years ago
    If I can do video Skype with it. The article made no mention, but it needs to have a front-facing camera, mic and speakers.
    Anonymous 2 years ago in reply to Anonymous
    Nokia's N900 (Maemo) boasts :(1) the best Skype integration for any smart phone.(2) the best browsing experience for any smartphone (3) shell access, unix utils, etc.It's still kinda rough around the edges, like rotation is waiting on the next release. Maemo was originally developed for tablet platforms but the N900 is currently a phone. I'm hoping that Nokia offers both form factors, cleans up the OS, and implements support for Android applications alongside Maemo.
    Anonymous 2 years ago
    It needs to have good battery life, PDF and ebook suppot and I'd buy one in lieu of an ebook reader. With video support, like HULU and/or Netflix and wow now it's a travel companion.And for more usefulness hi-cap SD card support, bluetooth and WIFI are musts. A nice base sized flash, say 32GB at a minimum.Yeah I'd buy one, or maybe the ipad, both can do more than the Sony PRS-600 I was going to buy. But the battery life is number one on my list, it has to last a good long time between charges. The 10 hours on the ipad sounds good, assuming it will actually run that long. Which ever device can pull of a 10 hour (or near 10 hour runtime) I will likely buy. Running out of juice on an airplane will turn your whatever pad into a flat useless brick you have to lug around, then the features you have or do not have don't really mean that much do they.
    Anonymous 2 years ago in reply to Anonymous
    Yes, they need to figure out a way for the CPU to take repeated short naps while the screen stays the same, for when you are reading down a page etc., and doing a fast transparent start.As for the fact that Apple has a patent on these two finger pinch and zoom features and will prevent them from being shipped. Why not an open source application that people use to 'teach' their phone this trick. Hard to put a cage on that.

      Add a comment

      Post a comment using one of these accounts
      Or join now
      At least 6 characters

      Note: Comment will appear soon after you have activated your account.
      Obscene/spam comments will be removed and accounts suspended.
      The information you submit is subject to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.

      ITworld LIVE

      Personal TechWhite Papers & Webcasts

      White Paper

      Checklist for an Employee-Owned Notebook or PC Program

      Download this complimentary Gartner report entitled Checklist for an Employee-Owned Notebook or PC Program and learn how to provide robust, scalable and secure access to corporate data, protect enterprise data and intellectual property, and more...

      White Paper

      The Complete Solution for Enabling BYO

      Download your complimentary solution brief to learn more about maximizing the effectiveness and security of these powerful business tools.

      White Paper

      How iPads® Enter the Workforce

      iPad has exploded onto the scene and new tablets are being introduced all the time. These post-PC devices will find a place in your company, but where? Download the report from Forrester Research for a framework to help guide best practices for supporting these devices o the workplace.

      White Paper

      BYO - Rethinking Your Device Strategy

      Provide your employees and contractors the freedom and flexibility to use their own computer for work-while eliminating security, control and support issues.

      Live Webcast October 13, 2011, 10:30 AM EST

      Consumerization: How IT Can Gain Control

      Attend this interactive webinar to discover: * The benefits of embracing and supporting consumerization * The benefits of supporting a Bring Your Own (BYO) policy * The role of desktop virtualization in helping IT gain control while users keep their independence * Best practices for rolling out a BYO initiative

      Sponsor: Citrix

      See more White Papers | Webcasts

      Ask a question

      Ask a Question