Tablet PCs: The Top 10 Missing Features

If you really want to make a tablet I'll buy, listen up.

By Tom Henderson  11 comments

PCs were curiosities until VisiCalc, WordStar, dBase, and even vi arrived. In the same way, PDAs were fun, but were initially just storage places for contacts and perhaps a few interesting apps. Cell phones were great because of their mobility -- a form factor. If you really want to make a tablet PC I'll buy, listen up:

1. The Media

The biggest problem with the future success of tablets is readily accessible media from as many publishers as possible. This means books, magazines, multimedia, and whatever we like. Nobody knows if we can go to a retailer, a captive Apple, Amazon, or whatever store to get our media. If it's just one vendor, then to hell with that. That vendor, by Murphy's Law, will instantly drop the content I'm looking for. Try it.

Image credit: osiello

2. Video Playback

Hulu. Gotta watch it. Episodes of Mad Men. Gotta watch it. SomethingTube. Gotta watch it. Must watch it on this device with no latency and in at least 720p and in excellent audio modes. Which brings to mind: audio.

3. Excellent audio playback

This has to be accomplished either with great internal speakers (sorry about that, Mr. BatteryLifeEngineer) or fabulous earphones that you'd never leave behind on an airplane because they sucked so badly.

4. USED MEDIA

That's right. I don't care how it's serialized, and if we have to pay a micro-buck to some damn licensing company or not, but I want to buy used books, magazines, and even 'episodes'. Don't give me a bunch of crap about various theories regarding licensing and DRM. DO it. Or they'll get stolen anyway whether we like it or not. Mark these words and stop making your lawyers rich -- make yourselves rich instead. I'll buy that old Michael Crichton novel, but don't think of charging me full retail pop for it. Won't happen.

5. 3G/4G/WiFi For Free

I'm about to buy a bunch of freaking media from you. I want to download it, and I don't want it to take all day and all my battery charge to do it. Subsidize the account already, and I'll even watch ads in the corner of the screen while you download it to me. Got that, Macmillan?

6. SD or Similar Memory Slot

I have my own media. It's not your media. I want it to playback on this machine, whenever I want it to. Give me the slot. If you don't give me the slot and make me tether it to my notebook or phone, I'm going to hate you.

7. Auto-adjusting Display

Let me change it, or let me read it in full sunshine or in the dark of the subway tunnel. Period. Figure it out. Full resolution. Ten hours battery life. Wow me with 3D glasses.

8. Include the Keyboard

No, I'm not tapping on the screen. It smudges. Give me a lightweight ASCII keyboard with F-keys/etc so that if I want, i can use it as a netbook. No, it won't cannibalize your overpriced notebook sales. Maybe.

9. Apps. Real Apps.

Do not make me captive to your cloud-based apps. If I want to do docs or spreadsheets or whatever, let me do it. Let me use somebody's software other than your own to do this. DO NOT MAKE ME GO TO THE WEB TO DO DOCS. You are warned.

10. Make Me Return For Great Deals

Ok, I'll read that #44 best seller if you discount it. Or maybe watch that concert with nearly dead rock stars. But you have to give us deals. I'm not at the arena, and I'm not paying TicketMaster. I'm sitting watching a tape backup and might consider a nicely priced video of Sheryl Crow doing a concert. That's if I can pay for it easily and rent it for a few days, because you never know when you'll have time to read.

11 comments

    Anonymous 1 year ago
    In my opinion a tablet PC should only be a physically thinner and lighter PC, with touch capabilities allowing a richer interaction and smaller form factor (= not need a keyboard + mouse), and computing power like (or more than) a laptop. All of the above aimed at achieving the best for mobility multi-purpose computing.The idea of the tablet PC as a means to "read and access multimedia contents" is in my opinion a limiting consumer-lock-in time-slave concept, since you'd end up needing the latest (fashionable) tablet PC to read the latest ebooks format, while a paper book or a newspaper just need the eyes humans used to own (for free) since well before the times of Alexandria's Great Library. The only excuse for a similar model would be the use of software like VNCviewer or RDP viewer, where the tablet PC is just the lighest-weight possible thin-client to connect to your office (or home) server where real full-fledged applications live.
    Anonymous 1 year ago
    I have been running Vista Ultimate on my Motion LE1600 since it was beta. There were some driver issues the first couple of months, but they have long since been fixed. Handwriting recognition in Vista is much better, but it comes at a cost of a slightly shorter battery duration. As I haven't used a keyboard with my tablet in the last 2 or 3 years (I rely on voice to text or handwriting to text), I think it counts as one piece. And mine functions just fine with Microsoft eReader and Sony book reader both installed on it, plus Zinio for magazines/newspapers and iTunes for music. It might be a little larger than you would want for a pure ereader, but given it also works as my notebook, my work laptop, and my iPod in addition to my ereader I think it is a great compromise.I agree that plain ereaders have a long way to go before they come close to my LE1600. If the Motion LS800 would have had better battery life, it would have been perfect.
    Anonymous 1 year ago
    This article was obviously written by a non-techie who doesn't know anything about computers.iPad is not a tablet. An ebook is not a tablet. What rock have you been living under? This isn't 1998. Go pick up a TouchNote from HP. I watched Hulu and Miro on that all day and use my keyboard when I do it. It was $800. I can even go online for free with my 3G cell phone. WOAH! Real apps? It runs Windows 7! What @#$%^&* app do you want? I can run anything!!!
    Anonymous 1 year ago
    I don't think you need a physical keyboard. I thought I'd use the keyboard on my Droid all the time...nope.Give me a freaking stylus man! I want to be able to write down notes instead of typing crap. Probably give it a stylus mode so I can rest my hand on the display while writing without the multi-touch sensors going nuts.On-line office products can be a pain, but I don't mind using them as long as there is a promise they will get better.
    Anonymous 1 year ago
    Where are you getting this information. Tablets have been around for years. Most of which keep up with a laptop. Unless your hopping on the iPad rage. This article is completely irrelevant to a true tablet PC.
    vtorch
    vtorch 1 year ago
    I don't understand, everything you mentioned can be done with a Tablet PC. Where have you been? Just look at the HP brands, they have been making full function tablet style PC's for years. For the exception of #5 on your list, everything can be done....and has been done. Again, where have you been?
    tomhenderson
    tomhenderson 1 year ago in reply to vtorch
    Let's review:1) Media-- it's missing2) Have you tried video on eReaders? Yes- it works on full-blown tablets from Fujitsu and others. Otherwise, try it on others. Let's see just how realistic it is.3) Again Fujitsu has it. Tried it on the Kindle K2?4) Used Media. Bah5) Free WiFi/3G/4G: show it to me. 6) SD slots, a few have. Does the venerable iPad?7) Auto-adjusting display from daylight to no-light. Not solved yet.8) Keyboards only come with full-blown machines, like the Fujitsus9) Real Apps-- see #810) I haven't seen any of the business plans that entice me yet. YMMV
    Anonymous 1 year ago
    I'd like to add that ebooks should not be more expansive than printed versions.
    Anonymous 1 year ago
    You just essentially described the HP TM2...
    Anonymous 1 year ago
    I have been using a Lenovo (formerly IBM) Thinkpad tablet PC for three years. I use it as my main PC at home and on the road. With my Palm Pre with MyTether I get 3G at no extra cost. Except having a self adjusting screen (it is manually adjustable) I think it is your perfect system. You can buy my old one, it bets the IPad on every score. I want to buy the latest model.
    Anonymous 1 year ago
    Real tablets have been around for a long time...you just haven't looked hard enough. Look at Motion Computing and Fujitsu for slate models. They are real laptops without keyboards - core 2 duo CPUs, 4GB RAM, 60GB hard disk running real Vista or XP Tablet PC edition and real Micorsoft Office. USB, bluetooth, SD slots, PCMCIA slots, Firewire ports...all the usual connectivity requirements. Same graphics and audio (speaker and headphone jack) as your standard laptop. With extended batteries they last 8 to 10 hours of normal use (ie: email and MS Office - not playing DVDs or streaming movies online). Most have WiFi and EVDO built in...but sorry, you have to pay for your own wireless plan to run it. Fictionwise, Zinio, eMagazines, project gutenburg, publishers like Baen and others all have digital media for sale or for free and they are independent of the device you use. The view anywhere screens from Motion are very good in anything but direct bright sunlight...bright indirect light isn't a problem. I use mine in my car and outside under trees in the park all the time. I don't use keyboards, handwriting to text conversion works just fine. Of course the screen isn't finger/touch sensitive...it uses a wacom digitizer so it needs a digital pen and maybe that doesn't meet your definition of a tablet. But it is the original definition of Tablet PC. If I need a keyboard, I have a fold-up bluetooth model I can use or I could get a USB based one. So really the only thing not out there on your list today is reselling of digital media (but you can pretty much get anything over 50 years old for free...thousands of classic books out there) and having the vendor pay for your wireless data plan.I am tired of people complaining about "when will tablets do what I want" when they peaked about 4 years ago and nobody but students and doctors and lawyers took note. And it got so bad that now Microsoft is disbanding it's Tablet PC group and rolling them into the core OS because there doesn't appear to be any real demand. If that trend holds, things will get worse, not better on the tablet front. Sorry for venting. Just wish people would use google a little to find out what already is out there before complaining it doesn't exist. Plenty of tablet pc forums out there already directing people on how to do almost everything you are talking about with existing technology.

      Add a comment

      Post a comment using one of these accounts
      Or join now
      At least 6 characters

      Note: Comment will appear soon after you have activated your account.
      Obscene/spam comments will be removed and accounts suspended.
      The information you submit is subject to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.

      ITworld LIVE

      Ask a question

      Ask a Question