Judge blocks Realtime Blackhole blacklisting
A Federal Court judge in Chicago Tuesday issued a temporary restraining order
against a nonprofit anti-spam group, prohibiting it from blacklisting an e-mail
marketing company with a 12 million e-mail account database.
The Mail Abuse Prevention System (MAPS) had threatened to place commercial e-mail
marketer Yesmail.com on its Realtime Blackhole List, an anti-spam alert system read by
thousands of ISPs, according to Yesmail.com.
MAPS would like to see Yesmail.com go with a double opt-in standard in order for a
user to receive e-mail. The double opt-in standard requires the users to request the e-
mail at a Web site and then confirm again that it is desired by replying to a
Chicago-based Yesmail.com, owned by Internet holding company CMGI says it supports
protective measures for users, but says MAPS is trying to strong-arm it into the
"They are very zealous that we turn our whole business model around," said Tony
Priore, Yesmail's senior vice president of marketing. "To totally change your business
model overnight, just to satisfy these guys, is ludicrous. We finally had to say enough
Redwood City, Calif.-based MAPS is a nonprofit that seeks to "defend the Internet's
e-mail system from abuse." MAPS officials could not be reached for comment, but a
message was posted Tuesday on the group's Web site.
"At this time, we can only confirm that Yesmail.com has filed a lawsuit against MAPS
and a temporary restraining order has been issued," the statement reads. "MAPS will
comment in more detail at a later time."
Yesmail.com officials sued MAPS late last week to keep itself off the blacklist that
can potentially cause as many as 20,000 ISPs to block its mail.
"Those are real consequences," Priore said. "The whole thing seems so out of
proportion and ludicrous."
Within its suit filed in a federal court in Illinois, Yesmail denies that it is a
spammer. Priore said the company has gone to "great pains" to guard and protect users'
Yesmail.com markets itself as a opt-in mail provider. Users must ask for e-mail to
be sent to them before it lands in their inbox. And Yesmail.com allows a user to remove
his or her name from its mailing list at any time.
Priore also said Yesmail utilizes the double opt-in standard for some of its direct
marketing clients. Yesmail.com officials had discussions with MAPS for several months
before it decided to file suit late last week, he said.