April 16, 2012, 10:52 AM —
Are you willing to keep your mouth shut?
Source: Sara G.../Flickr
Programmers in demand get approached by people about new projects. Demanding an NDA upfront starts the relationship off on the wrong foot.
Lawyers, paid to draft Non Disclosure Agreements, counsel their clients to make everyone they meet with about their new idea to sign an NDA. Programmers, vital to the modern business, get asked for advice all the time, but, as John Larson says, "will almost never sign an NDA."
Mixergy's Andrew Warner lists seven reasons explaining why programmers and consultants refuse to sign an NDA, including "Ideas are worthless," and "This reason is so secret that I can't reveal it … unless you sign an NDA." Starting a possible business relationship with a paper saying, "I don't trust you to keep our conversation private," sets an awkward vibe. Unless specific details, like private financial details, are involved, don't insult a programmer by waving an NDA as you start to explain your, "it's like Facebook but … " idea.
Right on, brother
I don’t sign NDAs unless it comes stapled with a $100k check. It’s such a drag.
melvinram on jpl-consulting.com
As an active angel I get emailed about 4 of these a day. Deletia, unfortunately.
joshu on news.ycombinator.com
You don’t get engaged on the first date, and you shouldn’t sign an NDA on the first phone call.
quanticle on jpl-consuling.com
I recently turned down a freelancing contract where the client asked me to "kindly keep this confidential".
babarock on news.ycombinator.com
Freedom for the ideas
The key to a signable NDA for me is specificity (you have to state what you're protecting) and time limits (typically 6-24 months after the information is disclosed).
jeffreymcmanus on mixergy.com
I think its time to stop signing NDAs on job interviews too. (Is anyone still doing this?)
nirvana on news.ycombinator.com
You missed a huge reason people require NDAs – to protect customer information.
Jim McNelis on jpl-consulting.com
All of your reasons are bunk.
crazyentrepreneur on mixergy.com
But keep in mind that sometimes an NDA is useful: You can use it to bash people who decide to break the honour code.
maxklein on mixergy.com
Hollywood plot and character details matter, and are often under NDA. So are ideas in the patent pipeline. But your "It's like Facebook" idea doesn't need an NDA, because others are already working on your idea.
For the latest IT news, analysis and how-tos, follow ITworld on Twitter, Facebook, and Google+.
Now read this:
Developer declares 'I am done with the Freemium Business Model'
Study says Facebook profile can predict job performance