December 02, 2013, 6:17 PM — Salesforce.com has completed a review of the judging process for the hackathon it held at last month's Dreamforce conference, and as a result it will award a second US$1 million prize to the initial runner-up.
The probe "determined that the winning teams met eligibility requirements, but that final round judges may not have been provided with enough information to evaluate final round entrants' use of pre-existing code contained in their app entries," Salesforce.com said in a statement on Monday. "As Salesforce.com is unable to determine whether or not this would have changed the outcome of the final round of judging, the company has concluded that the appropriate outcome is to declare a tie and award each of our two top winners the first place prize of $1 million."
Contestants worked to create mobile applications with Salesforce.com's development technology. The top prize of $1 million initially went to Upshot.
While the contest rules stated that applications had to be "developed solely as part of this Hackathon," other contestants complained, pointing out that it appeared Upshot CTO Thomas Kim had demoed a similar-sounding application a couple of weeks before the official coding start date of Oct. 25.
Critics also noted that Kim is a former Salesforce.com employee, and they questioned the eligibility of the team that created runner-up application Healthcare.love because they work at Taptera, a company in which Salesforce.com has invested.
Still other contestants claimed their entries didn't receive any evaluation from judges.
Salesforce.com CEO Marc Benioff took to Twitter last week after online complaints mounted, promising a full review of the hackathon was underway.
The results of that internal review largely exonerate Salesforce.com.
Although Kim used to work at Salesforce.com, "the rules only prohibited participation by former employees of Salesforce.com if they left the company after August 31, 2013, which is after the departure of [Kim] from Salesforce.com," according to Monday's announcement.
In addition, although Upshot's submission used pre-existing software code, this was allowable "as long as the code did not comprise the majority of the app and did not violate any third party's rights," the announcement adds. "The internal audit team's review determined that Upshot's mobile app was created during the hackathon and met these criteria."
However, the review also found that Salesforce.com didn't give judges "enough information to ensure that the scores for the 'innovation' criteria took into account use of pre-existing code."